Publishers Have Attention, Brands Have Transactions, and Each Needs What the Other Has
Why publishers must learn to sell, brands must learn to publish, and how the two can trade
The argument in one paragraph. For a century, publishers optimised for earning attention and brands for converting demand. Each outsourced the half it was weaker at: publishers rented distribution and left the money in their readers’ next steps to others; brands rented attention from platforms, increasingly to reach customers they already had. AI now squeezes both dependencies at once. Publishers must learn to sell, and brands must learn to earn attention, which is harder than owning a list. They can also become something new to each other: trading partners, with publishers supplying attention they have earned and brands supplying demand that pays only when a reader acts. Each has what the other lacks.
1 Two Industries, Two Halves of One Business
A newspaper and a bank look like different kinds of company. One produces stories; the other moves money. But underneath, every business that serves people at scale has to do two things. It has to earn their attention, and it has to turn some of that attention into something people pay for. Publishers and brands each became very good at one of these, and each organised itself around it.
Publishers built supply chains for attention. A newsroom produces something new every day, and the reader has a reason to come back tomorrow that has nothing to do with buying anything. That habit is the publisher’s great asset. A daily paper has fresh material almost every day of the month. The advantage is not the sending; it is that there is always something new worth sending.
Brands built supply chains for transactions. They know who their customers are, what they bought, what they might buy next, and how to take a payment, ship a product and handle a complaint. What most brands lack is a reason to be in a customer’s day when there is nothing to sell. Most have something new to say only a few times a month. Beyond that, a brand usually has to invent a reason, and an invented reason is usually a discount.
These are generalisations. Subscription publishers run serious customer operations, and the largest retailers now run media businesses. But the difference in what each side optimised for is real, and it explains much of what is happening to both.

Figure 1. Two industries optimised for opposite halves of the same business.
Publishers mastered earning attention. Brands mastered converting it. Neither mastered both.
2 Each Rented What It Lacked
What a business does not do itself, it rents. Publishers rented distribution. For two decades, search and social sent them most of their new readers, and the money in what those readers did next, such as buying, booking or applying, went to marketplaces, comparison sites and advertisers. Brands rented attention. They paid platforms to put them in front of people, and increasingly paid again to reach people who were already their customers but had stopped paying attention.
The two dependencies are mirror images, and they ran through the same small number of intermediaries. The three largest platform companies are expected to take 59.7% of global advertising spending outside China this year. I have written about owned and rented attention before, in “From Rented to Owned”; the point here is narrower. Both industries handed their weaker half to the same landlords.
Both industries outsourced their weaker half to the same intermediaries.
3 AI Squeezes Both Rentals at Once
For publishers, the squeeze is already visible. Answer engines summarise the story instead of sending the reader to it. Over two years, small publishers lost about 60% of their search referrals, mid-sized ones 47% and large ones 22%. Social and video networks have overtaken publishers’ own sites and apps as a source of news, according to the Reuters Institute. I made the case in “When Search Keeps the Answer”; it does not need repeating.
What is new is that the same shift is reaching brands. When a leading AI company let people buy inside its chatbot in September 2025, it described AI as becoming “a key interface for how people discover, decide, and buy”. Discovery was the publisher’s rental. Deciding and buying are the brand’s. An assistant that recommends the product, compares the options and completes the checkout stands between the brand and its own customer, just as it now stands between the publisher and its reader.
The intermediary that kept the publisher’s reader now wants the brand’s customer too.
4 Publishers Must Learn to Sell
A publisher that loses its free supply of strangers is left with the readers who come back on their own. Those readers are worth far more than strangers, but only if the publisher can do the things brands take for granted: recognise each reader, understand what they need, offer the right product at the right moment, take payment smoothly, and keep the customer.
Most publishers are early in this. Paying for news has stalled: across the markets the Reuters Institute surveys, only 17% pay for online news, essentially unchanged from a year earlier. Publishers are diversifying: among publishers surveyed by WAN-IFRA, revenue from sources other than advertising and reader payments, such as events and licensing, reached 25.4% of revenue in 2025. But much of it comes from events rather than from serving readers’ next steps. In “The Publisher’s Second Business” I argued that the opportunity lies in moving from telling readers what happened to helping them decide and act. That move needs a capability most newsrooms never built: conversion.
The difficulty is cultural as much as technical. A newsroom is trained to inform, not to sell, and rightly protective of the trust that makes it worth reading. Learning to sell without spending that trust is the publisher’s hardest lesson.
A publisher that knows its readers but cannot sell to them is leaving half its business to others.
5 Brands Must Learn to Publish
Brands face the opposite problem. Most have large lists of customers who once bought from them. They own the means of reaching those customers: the email addresses, the app installs, the consent. What they do not own is the customers’ attention. A brand with ten million customer emails has ten million permissions to ask for attention, not ten million engaged customers.
Owning reach is not earning attention. The gap between the two is why so many brand messages go unopened, and why brands pay platforms to reach people already on their own lists. Closing that gap means learning what publishers know: how to give people a reason to open when nothing is for sale. That might be a useful weekly digest, a utility such as a tracker or a calculator, a small daily habit, or a collection worth completing.
A brand does not need a newsroom to do this. It needs one recurring thing its customers want to receive. The hard parts are a steady supply of content, the credibility to be read rather than skimmed, and the discipline not to turn every message into a sale. Useful recurring messages have a far better chance of earning attention than a steady stream of offers, which train customers to wait for the next discount.
A list is permission to ask for attention, not attention itself.
6 The Shared Path
Seen this way, publishers and brands are on the same path, travelling it from opposite ends. Both start with owned reach: a permissioned way of reaching people. Both must turn it into earned attention: a reason to open, and to come back. And both must turn that attention into valuable action. Only the action at the end differs. For a publisher, it is advertising, a subscription, a transaction or a service. For a brand, it is a repeat purchase, a cross-sell, or a customer it never has to buy back.

Figure 2. The same three steps, with different money at the end.
Publishers are strong in the middle step and weak in the last one. Brands are strong in the last step and weak in the middle. That is why the two industries are converging. Publishers are moving into transactions, and brands into publishing, because each is trying to complete the path it was only ever half equipped to walk.
The architecture of attention is the same; only the money at the end differs.
7 Where They Collide: The Bank and the Financial Publisher
Convergence sounds tidy until two companies arrive at the same place. Consider a bank and a financial publisher, both chasing the same reader’s morning.
The financial publisher starts from journalism. It explains markets, interest rates and tax changes, and a loyal reader opens its newsletter every day. To make that relationship pay, it wants to move into decisions and actions: a portfolio tool, an investor course, a route to opening an account or buying a fund. The bank starts from transactions. It holds the reader’s salary, savings and loans, and sees them every time money moves. To stop paying platforms to sell its own customers a credit card, it wants a daily reason to be opened: a market digest, a budgeting utility, a weekly note on what the rate change means for their mortgage.
Both end up offering a daily financial briefing with a next step attached. That is convergence, but not equivalence. The bank holds balances, transaction histories and regulated obligations that the publisher does not; it can complete the transaction. The publisher can offer independent scrutiny and a range of views that a bank selling its own products cannot credibly provide; it can explain the alternatives. Their incentives differ too: the publisher earns from the reader’s attention, the bank from the reader’s money. A reader may well want both, but not two of the same thing every morning.
The same collision is coming in travel, where airlines publish destination guides and travel publishers sell trips; in education, in property and in health. If every brand becomes a publisher, the inbox floods, every message is worth a little less, and the scarce resource becomes the reader’s willingness to open anything at all.
When everyone publishes, the scarce thing is not content but a reason to open.
8 From Rivals to Trading Partners
There is another way for the two to meet. Instead of each trying to master the other’s half, they can trade. Publishers supply attention they have earned. Brands supply demand: offers, products, and a reason for a reader to act. The exchange happens where an engaged reader already is: an enquiry, a test-drive booking or an account opening started inside the publisher’s message, completed there where the email supports it, or through a short, secure hand-off where it does not.

Figure 3. Attention from one side, demand from the other, and useful, measurable actions in the middle.
This raises an obvious question. Publishers have sold advertising to brands for centuries, and sponsorships, lead generation, affiliate links and pay-per-action deals are not new. What would be different?
| Today’s arrangement | What could be better | What must be proved |
| Advertisers pay for exposure or clicks | They pay for verified, qualified actions | A lower cost per customer, lead or sale than the alternatives |
| The reader goes through several steps before acting | A short path from interest to action | Higher completion rates |
| Publisher and brand measure results separately | An agreed test of what was truly added | Value created, not just credit reassigned |
Table 1. What the trade has to improve on.
Selling actions is not new. Combining trusted attention, a short path to action and an agreed measure of what was truly added, in one commercial relationship, would be. None of the three is enough alone. A qualified action is not automatically an additional one, and a short path is worthless if the reader did not want to take it.
This changes what a brand has to do. A brand does not need to rebuild itself as a publisher to benefit from publishing. It can buy outcomes first. It pays when a reader acts, not when a reader is shown something, and it leaves the hard work of earning the attention to the people who are good at it.
The most interesting version of the trade involves the brand’s own customers. Today, a brand that wants a lapsed customer back often pays a platform to find that person again, at close to the price of a new one. Consider how the alternative would work:
- The overlap. A bank has customers who have stopped using its credit card. Some of them read a financial publisher’s newsletter every morning, and the bank cannot reach them economically through its own messages, which they no longer open.
- The permission. Matching happens through a privacy-preserving process, so neither side sees the other’s customer list. But matching protects data; it does not create permission. The reader must have agreed to relevant partner offers, and the bank must be allowed to use the overlap for this purpose.
- The relevant action. The newsletter offers those readers, clearly labelled, something connected to what they came to read: a calculator showing what the card’s new features would have saved them this year, with one step to reactivate it.
- The controlled test. Half the matched readers see the offer and half do not. The difference in reactivations between the two groups is the number of customers the publisher won back that would not otherwise have returned.
- The division of value. The bank pays an agreed price for each additional customer recovered, less than it would pay to buy them back. The publisher earns more per engaged reader than a display ad would bring, and keeps the reader’s goodwill because the offer was useful.
Each step can fail. The overlap may be small; permission may be missing; the action may not be wanted; the test may show the customers would have returned anyway. That is the point of setting it out this way: the trade has to prove itself one recovered customer at a time.
The first brand a publisher serves this way should be itself. Most media groups own subscription products, listings, job boards, education businesses and events. Each needs readers, and the group’s newsletters can send them, measured net of what would have happened anyway. Once that works, the same space can be offered to the publisher’s existing advertisers, and only then to brands it has never worked with.
Brands already pay for audiences close to the moment of action. Retail media, in which retailers sell advertising across their own sites and apps, is forecast to reach about $200 billion this year. That does not prove the publisher model; it shows the demand exists. Publishers hold a different kind of audience, one that comes back daily by choice, and they have barely begun to sell it this way.
Better to buy attention from those who earned it than to rent it from those who intercept it, and to pay only when someone acts.
9 The Reader Must Come Out Ahead
Publishers gain revenue from the trade, and brands gain customers. The reader risks getting more commercial messages. If that is all the reader gets, the trade will not last, because the publisher will be selling the very attention it is spending.
The difference lies in relevance. A financial newsletter that inserts an unrelated insurance promotion because the advertiser pays for leads is spending its reader’s goodwill. A newsletter that offers a reader who follows retirement planning a clearly labelled retirement calculator, with an optional enquiry, is extending what the reader came to do.
The best commercial action should feel like a useful next step, not an interruption.
Four further conditions make the trade fair:
- A brand reaches its own customers through a publisher only where the reader has agreed, and without either side exposing its customer data to the other.
- Brands pay for actions that would not have happened anyway, measured against a holdout, not for impressions or for customers who would have returned regardless.
- Attention kept. Commercial actions are tested for their effect on readers coming back. If readers start to ignore the newsletter, the publisher has sold its future to pay for its present.
- Fair division. The publisher earned the attention; the brand supplied the reason to act. Both deserve a share, and neither can be squeezed for long without the trade collapsing.
10 What Would Prove This Wrong
Each of these tests can be read within two years, against a suitable comparison group:
| Hypothesis | What would challenge it |
| Publishers can learn to sell | Subscription and transaction revenue stays flat despite investment in identity and customer lifecycle |
| Brands can learn to publish | Brand digests and utilities fail to build habits, and engagement decays to the level of promotional email |
| The trade beats the alternatives | Advertisers cannot get a lower cost per additional recovered customer, qualified lead or sale than their next-best option, or publishers earn no more per engaged reader than from display advertising |
| Permission-based matching works | Consent rules or customer reluctance stop brands reaching their own customers through publishers |
| Readers come out ahead | Commercial actions reduce readers’ voluntary return, raise complaints or hurt subscription renewal compared with readers who do not see them |
| The inbox remains a refuge | AI assistants summarise both publishers’ and brands’ messages, and human opens collapse |
Table 2. Six falsification tests.
11 The Next Generation Does Both
For most of the last century, it was enough to be good at one half of the business. Publishers earned attention and let others convert it. Brands converted demand and paid others for attention. The intermediaries that made this division workable are now taking more from both sides, and the answer engines are about to take more still.
The companies that thrive from here will do both halves, or trade with someone who does the other. Publishers will learn to sell without spending the trust that makes them worth reading. Brands will learn to publish without turning every message into an offer. And the most interesting businesses may be the ones that connect them: publishers supplying attention they have earned, brands supplying demand, and readers getting something useful in the exchange.
Publishers spent a century learning to earn attention; brands spent a century learning to convert it. The next generation will need to do both, or learn to trade.