The Publisher’s Second Business

From telling readers what happened to helping them decide what to do next

The argument in one paragraph. For a century, publishers built their businesses around one job: telling people what happened. Readers have two more jobs, deciding what it means for them and doing something about it, and most of the value in those went elsewhere. Publishers once held part of it, through classifieds, and lost it to better software. AI now makes it cheaper to turn editorial knowledge into tools and services, but the same assistants that keep the answer also want the decision and the action. A publisher can build a second business only where it holds something the assistant lacks, can run it reliably, and can find someone who will pay. It need not own the screen: it can build the tool, supply the assistant, or partner with whoever completes the task. What matters is not who controls the interface, but who owns something the decision cannot do without.

1  The Business Newspapers Already Lost

For most of the twentieth century, a newspaper ran two businesses under one masthead. The first told readers what had happened. The second helped them act: find a job, rent a flat, sell a car, hire a plumber. That second business was classified advertising, and it was enormous. In 2000, American newspapers earned $19.6 billion from classifieds, about 40% of all their advertising revenue. Recruitment ads alone brought in $8.7 billion.

Within a decade most of it had gone. By 2009, classified revenue had fallen to roughly $6 billion; by 2012 it was $4.6 billion, down about 77%. Help-wanted advertising, the most valuable category, lost more than 90%. Many newspaper groups saw it coming and invested in online sites such as Cars.com, CareerBuilder and Apartments.com, which, as a Congressional Research Service report notes, drew classified advertising away from the papers’ own pages. Reach and a famous masthead were not enough. The winners had better software: search, filters, alerts and a market that grew more useful with every listing.

Figure 1. Publishing’s first second business, and how fast it went.

Publishers have had a second business before. They lost it because matching people with things went to whoever built the best software.

Some media groups did hold on to large second businesses, and those businesses grew bigger than the journalism. When Axel Springer split itself in two, its classifieds businesses, including the StepStone jobs platform and the Aviv property group, accounted for about €10 billion of a €13.5 billion valuation. Schibsted sold its newspapers to its main owner for about $570 million; its marketplaces stayed listed as a separate company. The Washington Post Company earned $2.9 billion, or 62% of its revenue, from its Kaplan education business in 2010, and when it sold the newspaper in 2013, it kept Kaplan.

These cases prove less than they seem to. Kaplan was bought, not built from the newsroom; it entered higher education by acquiring a chain of colleges. Marketplaces won on network effects and software, not on reporting. They show that media companies can own valuable businesses beyond journalism. They do not show that journalism itself can be turned into one.

Publisher Second business Built from the journalism? What happened
US newspapers Classified advertising Partly: local reach, not newsroom knowledge Lost most of it to specialist marketplaces
Axel Springer Job and property marketplaces No: separate marketplace businesses About three-quarters of group value; separated from the newsroom
Schibsted Online marketplaces No: marketplace software Newspapers sold to the founding trust
Washington Post Co. Education No: acquired Grew to 62% of revenue; newspaper sold, Kaplan kept
Dow Jones Professional information Closer: news archives, data and expertise About 40% of revenue and growing (section 4)

Table 1. Most successful second businesses were acquired or built as separate software businesses.

The distinction matters for what follows. A publisher can acquire a second business, as media groups have done for decades. The more interesting opportunity is to build one from the knowledge, relationships and expertise that publishing itself creates. History offers few examples of the second kind. Diversification of the first kind is already well under way: according to WAN-IFRA, revenue from “other” activities such as events and business services reached 25.4% of surveyed publishers’ revenue in 2025, up from 13.2% in 2021. This essay is about why knowledge-led second businesses may now become possible, and when they make sense.

2  Know, Decide, Do

Every reader has three jobs. Know: what happened? Decide: what does it mean for me? Do: what is my next step? Publishing has concentrated on the first, and the first has a public value no business model fully captures. But commercially, the middle job went to whoever stood nearest the decision: the search box, the comparison site, the broker, the adviser, the software vendor. Much of the third went to marketplaces.

Consider a local paper reporting that the city’s schools have changed their admission rules: new catchment boundaries, a lottery for oversubscribed schools, earlier deadlines. That is Know, and it is good journalism. But a parent reading it has a bigger problem. Which schools is my child now eligible for? How do they compare on the things I care about? When must I apply, and what documents do I need?

The paper already holds much of the knowledge to answer those questions. It has reported on every school for years. It knows the rules and the officials who wrote them. Yet it publishes the story and stops, and the parent takes the next step somewhere else, or alone.

Figure 2. Three jobs. Publishers kept the first; others captured the value in the next two.

The article informs the decision. The larger commercial opportunity often lies in helping the reader make it.

3  What Publishers Already Hold

A publisher setting out to help readers decide and act does not start from nothing. It holds six assets that most new entrants would have to build or buy:

  • Damaged, but still real. Trust in news stands at 37% across the markets the Reuters Institute surveys, a record low, yet a known masthead still carries more authority than an anonymous site.
  • Specialist expertise. Reporters who have covered schools, markets or one industry for years know where the traps are.
  • Verified archives. Decades of checked facts, figures and context.
  • Readers who come back on their own and have said what they care about.
  • Local knowledge. People on the ground who know which rule changed and which provider cut corners.
  • Convening power. The ability to bring people facing the same decision together.

Assets are not advantages until they are tested. An archive that any assistant can summarise is not proprietary intelligence. Trust in a headline is not permission to give regulated advice. And audience size is missing from the list on purpose: newspapers had huge audiences when they lost classifieds. An audience is a reason to try a second business, not a reason it will work.

The right question is not “what can we sell to our readers?” but “what can we help them do better than anyone else?”

4  When Knowledge Becomes Software

Until recently, turning editorial knowledge into a product meant hiring software teams and data engineers and waiting years. Only the largest publishers could afford it, and those that did built some of the best businesses in the industry. Dow Jones’s professional information arm, which sells risk, compliance and energy intelligence to companies, now accounts for around 40% of Dow Jones revenue, and management says a significantly greater share of its profit. Its Risk & Compliance unit grew 19% to $100 million in a single quarter this year. It is the clearest case of a knowledge-led second business at scale, built on news archives, data and editorial judgement.

AI changes who can try. A regional publisher can now build a working prototype of an answer service over its archive, a calculator that applies this year’s rules or a checklist that knows the local deadlines, in weeks rather than years. That is a prototype, not a product. Turning it into a service people rely on still means ingesting and verifying data, updating it when rules change, supporting users, securing their information and clearing the rights. Those costs can dwarf the cost of the first demonstration.

So AI does not remove the hard part; it moves it. Building gets cheaper; maintaining matters more. A wrong answer in a decision tool costs the reader far more than a wrong fact in an article. Accuracy, provenance and human oversight become the main operating cost of a second business, and its main source of value.

AI’s biggest opportunity for publishers may not be cheaper journalism. It may be more businesses that journalism can support.

5  The Assistant Wants the Same Job

There is an obvious objection, and it could sink the argument. The companies building AI assistants say plainly where they are heading. When OpenAI let users buy products inside ChatGPT in September 2025, it described AI as becoming “a key interface for how people discover, decide, and buy”. That is Know, Decide and Do in a single sentence. Assistants that summarise the news will also compare schools, model a loan and book an appointment. If they keep the answer, why would they not keep the decision and the action too?

Often they will. Generic decisions, such as the cheapest flight or the best-rated vacuum cleaner, will go to whoever has the widest reach and the best interface. That is the classifieds lesson again. Publishers without a differentiated asset have little reason to compete head-on with general-purpose assistants. Three assets are harder for an assistant to supply:

  • Verified, proprietary or local data. This year’s admission rules for one city’s schools, the cut-offs for a regional exam, the tradespeople who did the job properly. Information gathered and checked on the ground is often not on the open web, or not reliably.
  • A named institution that answers when it is wrong. When the stakes are money, health or a child’s education, people want someone answerable, not just an answer.
  • People who trust each other through the publisher: parents in the same district, investors in the same sector. Much of the value comes from the others in the room.

Holding one of these is necessary but not sufficient. A publisher may have trusted reporting on schools but no accurate, current admissions data. It may have a community but not the expertise to run a service reliably. It may be accountable but unable to serve thousands of users economically. A second business has to pass three tests:

  1. Do we hold data, accountability or community that an assistant cannot cheaply reproduce?
  2. Can we turn that advantage into a reliable, maintained product?
  3. Will readers or institutions pay enough, repeatedly, to make it profitable?

Figure 3. Three tests for a second business, and what to do when one fails.

Passing the first test creates an opportunity. Passing all three makes it a plausible business.

Job Assistant’s advantage Publisher’s possible edge Where the publisher stands
Know: general news summary Reach, speed, convenience Original reporting, provenance Best as a licensed source
Decide: generic product choice Breadth, comparison at scale Little Stay out
Decide: local or high-stakes choice Convenience Verified data, named experts Can compete, if all three tests pass
Do: generic purchase Checkout inside the conversation Little Stay out
Do: local service or application Convenience Verified providers, community Can compete, often through a partner

Table 2. The assistant’s default advantage, and where a publisher can still compete.

6  The Interface Isn’t the Business

Return to the parent. Suppose a regional publisher keeps the most accurate, current information about local schools: rules, catchments, deadlines, results. The parent does not visit the publisher’s site. She asks her assistant which school her child is eligible for. Three outcomes are possible.

  • The publisher runs its own eligibility checker and deadline tracker, and earns from readers who use it.
  • The assistant answers using the publisher’s verified data, under a paid licence, with the source named.
  • The publisher guides the parent, and an accountable specialist, such as a school-admissions service, completes the application, with any commercial relationship disclosed.

Only the first requires the parent to come to the publisher’s own screen. As assistants become the place where decisions start, the second and third may matter more. Supplying is different from licensing an archive for training: what is sold is live, maintained, verified knowledge, priced on use, and its value depends on being kept right. That is a business an assistant cannot easily build for itself, because it rests on people on the ground and an institution that answers for errors.

Figure 4. Three ways to turn trusted knowledge into a second business.

What matters is not who controls the interface, but who owns something the decision cannot do without.

7  Four Second Businesses

Four domains show where the tests are passed most often. Two deserve depth, because they show both the promise and the hardest question: who pays.

Professional intelligence is the proof that a knowledge-led second business can be large. Industry news tells a manager what changed. The second business tells the company what a new regulation means for it, whether a counterparty is safe and what to watch next, delivered inside the work through screening, monitoring and alerts. The advantage is proprietary, structured data plus accountability, and the customer is a company that pays for reliability because errors are expensive. Dow Jones shows the scale this can reach. It also shows the cost: the data must be maintained continuously, enterprise buyers are demanding, and liability comes with the territory. It proves the category, not that a small newsroom can copy it.

Education shows where the economics get hard. Education pages already report exam dates, results and policy changes. The second business helps a student or parent decide which exam, course or school fits, then do the work: eligibility checks, practice, assessments, applications and learning plans. The advantage is verified local data and a high-stakes need. But who pays for a school-admissions tool? A parent may use it intensely for a few weeks and never again. Schools paying for placement create an immediate conflict. The options each change the business: a membership that bundles the tool with other services, a contract with an education authority, sponsorship kept visibly separate from rankings, or supplying the verified data to the services and assistants parents already use. A reader’s need does not automatically mean a willingness to pay.

Finance follows the professional model for consumers: calculators, plain-language explainers and investor education, with next steps routed to licensed partners. Its boundary is regulation; in most markets, explaining is journalism, but personalised investment advice needs a licence. Local turns civic reporting into verified directories, bookings, events and memberships. Its advantage is local data and community; its risk is becoming one more directory, so “verified” has to mean something.

Domain Decide Do Likely model Who pays
Professional What this means for my company Screening, monitoring, alerts Build Enterprises, through licences
Education Which exam, course, school Eligibility, practice, applications Build, supply or partner Hard: members, institutions, licensees
Finance What this means for my money Next steps via licensed partners Build and partner Subscribers; disclosed partner fees
Local Which contractor, clinic, school Verified directory, bookings, events Build and partner Members, verified providers, events

Table 3. Four second businesses, each built on knowledge the publisher already holds.

8  The Trust Tax

Every second business tempts a publisher to spend the trust that makes it possible. A lender will pay for leads. A school will pay to be listed first. A retailer will pay a commission on every sale. Readers may trust a publisher’s journalism without wanting it to become their broker or their adviser.

Kaplan is the cautionary case, even though it was acquired rather than built from the newsroom. A Senate committee found that Kaplan’s higher-education business drew 85.9% of its 2010 revenue from federal student aid, and 87.9% including military education benefits. The same investigation documented aggressive recruiting and high withdrawal rates, while also crediting the company with significant later reforms. Meanwhile the parent company’s chief executive led the industry’s effort to soften new federal rules, as his newspaper covered the same policy fight. A second business had put the first in an awkward position.

The boundaries are not complicated, but they have to be built in from the start:

  • Editorial independence. The newsroom does not write for the second business’s clients.
  • Every commercial relationship and ranking method is visible at the point of decision.
  • Reader data is used only for what the reader agreed to.
  • Information, advice and advertising are labelled and kept apart.
  • Licences and oversight. Where advice is regulated, the publisher holds the licence or works through someone who does, with expert review and a visible process for complaints and corrections.

The hardest case is a service that succeeds commercially while trust in the newsroom falls. A publisher should decide in advance which trust measures would trigger a review, and be prepared to change or close the service if they move.

Trust is the asset only if the second business does not spend it.

9  Who Can Afford a Second Business?

Smaller publishers are under the most pressure. Over two years, small publishers lost about 60% of their search referrals, mid-sized ones 47% and large ones 22%. But pressure is not capability. Many smaller publishers lack product teams, capital, proprietary datasets or enough customers to support a software service. Some will do better through membership, philanthropy or specialist reporting than through any second business.

For those that do have an advantage, three structures are feasible without a large balance sheet: a focused local utility that does one job well; a shared service built with peers, so that several publishers spread the cost of the data and the technology; or a supply or partner arrangement that turns their verified knowledge into revenue without building a product at all.

Smaller publishers may need a second business most, but need is not evidence that they can build one.

10  The Economics of the Second Business

The test is contribution, not traffic. Contribution means revenue minus the costs that a second business adds: maintaining data, expert review, technology, support, liability, distribution and acquiring customers. A decision tool used by a few thousand people who renew every year can be worth more than an article read by a million, or it can lose money on every user. Only the arithmetic, against a fair baseline, will say which.

Revenue comes in several forms: subscriptions to tools, service fees, licences to businesses and assistants, disclosed partner fees, and events and memberships. Most second businesses will combine two or three.

The organisation sits beside the newsroom, not inside it. Journalists supply the knowledge; product builders turn it into tools; editorial standards govern both. Start narrow: one decision readers face repeatedly, with high stakes, where all three tests can plausibly be passed.

Governance needs deciding early. Table 1 showed what happens when a second business succeeds: when it is worth more than the journalism, investors want the two apart. A publisher should decide at the outset whether its second business exists to fund journalism, and design ownership accordingly.

11  What Would Prove This Wrong

Each of these tests can be run within 12 to 24 months, against a suitable comparison group:

Hypothesis Evidence that would challenge it
Publishers hold a real advantage Users of a publisher’s decision tool report no added value over a general assistant, and usage falls as assistants add the same features
Someone will pay Free use is high, but trials do not convert into recurring payments, licences or other revenue that covers costs
AI lowers the cost enough Verifying, updating and supporting the product consume most of its gross profit
Trust survives commerce Trust in the publisher falls among users exposed to the service, relative to those who are not
The interface need not be owned Publishers cannot earn from their knowledge either directly or by supplying assistants and partners
It is not only for giants After 24 months, profitable examples remain limited to the largest publishers

Table 4. Six falsification tests.

12  The Publisher of 2030

The publisher of 2030 will still be defined by its journalism. Reporting earns the trust, the expertise and the relationships that every second business depends on. Without the first business, there is no second one.

But journalism no longer needs to be the only product. Not every publisher will become a software company; not every archive will become a product; not every reader wants a publisher to act on their behalf. Those with a clear right to win will turn their knowledge into something readers and institutions can use: to choose a school, manage their money, run a business or find their way in their own city. Some will own the service. Others will power it from behind an assistant, or through a partner. The question for 2030 is not how many articles a publisher produces, but what people can reliably do because that publisher exists.

The first business of publishing was making information worth reading. The second may be making knowledge worth using.

Published by

Rajesh Jain

An Entrepreneur based in Mumbai, India.

Leave a Reply