How Agentic AI will Transform Digital Marketing (Part 6)

Agentic AI – 3

ChatGPT

Agentic AI involves the design and deployment of artificial intelligence systems that possess a degree of self-governance, enabling them to perform tasks and make decisions autonomously based on predefined objectives. These systems are characterized by their ability to interpret their environments, respond to changes, and initiate actions without human intervention. Common applications include autonomous vehicles that navigate traffic, robots that perform complex tasks in variable conditions, and smart systems that manage home or industrial operations. The development of agentic AI requires integrating advanced machine learning algorithms, cognitive computing techniques, and robust decision-making frameworks to ensure they can handle real-world unpredictability and complexity safely and effectively.”

Gemini

Taking Charge: Autonomy is Key

  • Unlike traditional AI designed for specific tasks, Agentic AI is built to pursue complex goals and workflows with minimal human oversight.
  • Imagine an AI assistant that can not only book your travel but also handle unexpected delays, re-routing your trip and updating your itinerary on the fly.

Smarter Decisions: Planning and Adapting

  • Agentic AI can break down complex tasks into subtasks, reason through them, and make decisions based on the situation.
  • This allows it to adapt to changing circumstances. For instance, an agentic AI system managing inventory might adjust ordering patterns based on real-time sales data.

Understanding the Context: Natural Language Power

  • Agentic AI can understand and interpret complex information, including natural language instructions and goals.
  • This enables more sophisticated interactions, allowing humans to communicate with the AI in a natural way.

The Benefits of Agentic AI

  • Increased Efficiency: Automating complex workflows and adapting to changing situations can significantly improve efficiency.
  • Reduced Costs: Less human oversight translates to reduced labor costs.
  • Enhanced Innovation: Agentic AI can explore new possibilities and solutions, aiding human creativity.
  • Personalized Experiences: AI agents can tailor their actions and services based on individual needs and preferences.

The Future of Agentic AI

This technology is still under development, but it holds immense potential across various industries. Here are some areas where agentic AI might make a significant impact:

  • Enterprise Automation: Streamlining complex back-office processes and supply chain management.
  • Customer Service: Providing personalized and efficient support through AI chatbots and virtual assistants.
  • Financial Services: Optimizing investment strategies and fraud detection.
  • Healthcare: Assisting doctors with diagnoses and treatment plans.

[Rajesh] AI agents mark a significant evolution from traditional LLM-based chatbots like ChatGPT, which primarily assist with content creation, coding, and pattern-matching tasks. While chatbots utilise large language models to analyse data and generate responses, AI agents enhance this by autonomously making decisions, initiating actions, and adapting in real-time. This capability transforms them from reactive tools into proactive partners, opening new avenues for business innovation. These agents are set to revolutionise industries by automating complex decision-making processes and boosting operational efficiencies, particularly in roles like Co-Marketers and Digital Twins in digital marketing. This is what we will explore next.

Thinks 1257

FT: “Four Chinese generative artificial intelligence start-ups have been valued at between $1.2bn and $2.5bn in the past three months, leading a pack of more than 260 companies vying to emulate the success of US rivals such as OpenAI and Anthropic. The newly minted unicorns — Zhipu AI, Moonshot AI, MiniMax and 01.ai — have gained significant backing from a largely domestic pool of investors and are fighting to hire the best talent to develop the most popular AI products. “There is no winner of foundation models yet in the China market. These are some of the names leading the charge to claim that title,” said Charlie Dai, vice-president and principal analyst at tech-focused consultancy Forrester.”

Arnold Kling: “While power has become more concentrated, knowledge has become more dispersed. In the economy, people are increasingly specialized. Science, medicine, and engineering have split into smaller sub-disciplines. In general, policy makers have too little knowledge relative to the high concentration of power. Consider the bills passed in [the US] Congress that run to hundreds of pages, which is more than they can read. And often the bills merely delegate power to unelected officials in government agencies.

Reuters: “Prominent computer scientist Fei-Fei Li is building a startup that uses human-like processing of visual data to make artificial intelligence (AI) capable of advanced reasoning, six sources told Reuters, in what would be a leap forward for the technology….She said the cutting edge of research involved algorithms that could plausibly extrapolate what images and text would look like in three-dimensional environments and act upon those predictions, using a concept called “spatial intelligence.” To illustrate the idea, she showed a picture of a cat with its paw outstretched, pushing a glass toward the edge of a table. In a split second, she said, the human brain could assess “the geometry of this glass, its place in 3D space, its relationship with the table, the cat and everything else,” then predict what would happen and take action to prevent it. “Nature has created this virtuous cycle of seeing and doing, powered by spatial intelligence,” she said.”

Benn Steil and Manuel Hinds: “Development requires helping the poor find their way from farm to factory, and from factory to office, classroom, and laboratory. This requires massive investment, which in turn requires sophisticated financial intermediation. It is for this reason that the trade and financial dimensions of globalization are complementary.” [via CafeHayek]

WSJ: “Rain starts as water vapor high in the sky; the individual water molecules float free of one another, mixed in with the other gases that make up the atmosphere. When the conditions are right, they condense to join a liquid water droplet or freeze solid onto an ice crystal. At the start, these solid or liquid particles are very small and just drift along with the air currents. But as they grow in mass, they start to fall. Lots of raindrops start off as ice crystals and melt as they fall into warmer air. Once all the droplets are liquid and falling, the dance really gets going. The smallest raindrops are around two thousandths of an inch across. These baby drops are spherical because the surface tension of the liquid squeezes the total surface area to be as compact as possible. Physicists find it strange that people often draw raindrops with a pointy end at the top, because the surface tension makes sure that there are no sharp corners—they’re all smoothed out incredibly quickly. Raindrops never have points.”

How Agentic AI will Transform Digital Marketing (Part 5)

Agentic AI – 2

Daniel Warfield writes: “It’s quickly becoming apparent that, while LLMs are exciting, they’re not a silver bullet. AI needs clever designers to wrangle it into a focused and powerful offering so it can actually be useful to consumers. Agentic systems seem to be the shining north star towards building successful LLM powered applications…Imagine if, instead of asking a language model to give you some output immediately, you asked a language model to do things like this: “You’ve been given a complex question, think about what to do next”, “You have access to a few tools, think about which one you can use them to best assist the user”, “You just output some information. Was it correct? Would you like to revisit that idea or move on?”. Essentially, Agents create a framework which allows a language model to reason about it’s previous output and decide to use tools to seek external sources of information.

Andrew Ng has been discussing this in his newsletters.

March 6, 2024: “Although today’s research agents, whose tasks are mainly to gather and synthesize information, are still in an early phase of development, I expect to see rapid improvements. ChatGPT, Bing Chat, and Gemini can already browse the web, but their online research tends to be limited; this helps them get back to users quickly. But I look forward to the next generation of agents that can spend minutes or perhaps hours doing deep research before getting back to you with an output. Such algorithms will be able to generate much better answers than models that fetch only one or two pages before returning an answer.”

March 20, 2024: Today, we mostly use LLMs in zero-shot mode, prompting a model to generate final output token by token without revising its work. This is akin to asking someone to compose an essay from start to finish, typing straight through with no backspacing allowed, and expecting a high-quality result. Despite the difficulty, LLMs do amazingly well at this task! With an agent workflow, however, we can ask the LLM to iterate over a document many times. For example, it might take a sequence of steps such as: plan an outline, decide what, if any, web searches are needed to gather more information, write a first draft, read over the first draft to spot unjustified arguments or extraneous information, revise the draft taking into account any weaknesses spotted, and so on. This iterative process is critical for most human writers to write good text. With AI, such an iterative workflow yields much better results than writing in a single pass.

Andrew shared a framework for categorising design patterns for building agents:

  • Reflection: The LLM examines its own work to come up with ways to improve it.
  • Tool Use: The LLM is given tools such as web search, code execution, or any other function to help it gather information, take action, or process data.
  • Planning: The LLM comes up with, and executes, a multistep plan to achieve a goal (for example, writing an outline for an essay, then doing online research, then writing a draft, and so on).
  • Multi-agent collaboration: More than one AI agent work together, splitting up tasks and discussing and debating ideas, to come up with better solutions than a single agent would.

This video has more. [Kitty (Sijia) Shen has a summary.]

Thinks 1256

Arnold Kling: “It takes a long time for people to accept that an industry is dying. Twenty years ago, people who worked as reporters or editors at local newspapers still thought they had a future. More recently, I have a relative who worked in the Hollywood ecosystem who ignored my warnings that his occupation was threatened. And there are plenty of young people who want to try becoming college professors. All of these are instances where the consumer demand still exists. People consume plenty of news. They consume more entertainment than ever. And people want to learn. The problem is with the business models of the legacy providers. The demand is there, but they are not meeting it efficiently. As the market evolves, someone who wants employment in a declining segment ought to adapt. Instead of adapting, too often people go into denial and end up yelling at consumers to stop choosing their preferred options.”

IBD: “”The AI vector search market is nascent,” said JPMorgan analyst Pinjalim Bora in a [recent] report. “The main ask from enterprise (customers) is how to empower LLMs (large language models) with proprietary enterprise data, while at the same time preserving the privacy and governance of the data.”…In the long-run, vector technology will play a role in search across massive data sets of semi-structured and unstructured data — images, social media posts, emails, audio files and sensor data. “Traditional databases are optimized for storing data such as tables, documents, and key-value pairs,” added JPMorgan’s Bora. “However, with advancements in AI and natural language processing, increasing quantities of semantic vector data have required new repositories. Vectors allow for storing the intrinsic meaning of unstructured content, such as images, videos and natural language in a machine-readable format.””

New Yorker: “However dynamic or sociable they become, Web-site home pages will continue to reckon with the structural problems of the social Internet. Facebook still works to track its users around the Internet, and uses the data to target them with advertising. Readers often log on to publications like the Times with their Gmail accounts, further entrenching Google as a Internet gatekeeper. Consumers’ attention is still largely dictated by algorithmic feeds, and TikTok continues to provide the best opportunity to draw new eyeballs, at least until it gets banned by the United States government. Individual sites trying to replicate the dynamism of social platforms must reckon with the fact that they are doing so at a far smaller scale. Loyal audiences are pointedly not everyone; there is a limit to how much revenue can be juiced from them. Moving away from the traffic firehose of the wider Internet seems counterintuitive, in that sense, but it may be the only viable option left.”

WSJ: “Artificial intelligence is making it possible for companies to replace humans in tasks that range from modeling sweaters to participating in clinical trials. AI systems can take in data on a person’s individual characteristics—such as appearance, shopping preferences and health profile—then predict how they would look in an item of clothing, how they would answer a question or be affected by a disease. This AI content, sometimes referred to as a person’s digital twin, is already being used for a variety of tasks. Los Angeles-based startup AI Fashion uses photos of real models to generate completely new AI images of them modeling various pieces of clothing for fashion campaigns and e-commerce sites. Another startup, Brox AI, created digital versions of 27,000 individuals, with information about their brand preferences and shopping habits, that allows companies to ask the AI focus-group-style questions. And San Francisco-based Unlearn is using AI to generate digital twins of people based on their health data to predict how disease might progress over time for those individuals—aiming to make clinical trials more efficient and effective.”

Nate Silver: “I think political beliefs are primarily formulated by two major forces: Politics as self-interest. Some issues have legible, material stakes. Rich people have an interest in lower taxes. Sexually active women (and men!) who don’t want to bear children have an interest in easier access to abortion. Members of historically disadvantaged groups have an interest in laws that protect their rights. Politics as personal identity — whose team are you on. But other issues have primarily symbolic stakes. These serve as vehicles for individual and group expression — not so much “identity politics” but politics as identity. People are trying to figure out where they fit in — who’s on their side and who isn’t. And this works in both directions: people can be attracted to a group or negatively polarized by it. People have different reasons for arguing about politics, and can derive value from a sense of social belonging and receiving reinforcement that their choices are honorable and righteous.”

How Agentic AI will Transform Digital Marketing (Part 4)

Agentic AI – 1

Note: I want to thank Gautam Mehra, co-founder and CEO of ProfitWheel, for introducing me to the world of Agentic AI.

Volodymyr Zhukov writes: “Agentic AI marks a fundamental shift in the very nature of artificial intelligence. It describes a class of AI systems specifically designed to understand complex workflows and pursue intricate goals autonomously, with little to no human intervention. In essence, agentic AI functions more like a human employee, grasping the complex context and instructions provided in natural language, embarking on goal-setting, reasoning through subtasks, and adapting decisions and actions based on changing conditions… Agentic AI can automate and optimize operations, adding significant value to business processes. These enhancements go beyond mere automation, offering advanced problem-solving capability and strategic planning to tackle complex tasks.” He lists the features that set it apart:

  • Autonomy: Unlike traditional AI systems, agentic AI is built to take initiative, performing directed actions independently, without constant human supervision.
  • Reasoning: Agentic AI possesses an advanced degree of decision-making, allowing it to make contextual judgments, weigh trade-offs, and set strategic actions.
  • Adaptable planning: In dynamic and changeable conditions, agentic AI demonstrates flexibility and responsiveness, adjusting its goals and plans based on the prevailing circumstances.
  • Language understanding: With an advanced ability to comprehend and interpret natural language, agentic AI can meticulously follow complex instructions, enhancing its capability to tackle sophisticated operations.
  • Workflow optimization: Agentic AI exhibits an uncanny skill to move fluidly between subtasks and applications, executing processes with optimum efficiency while ensuring the end goal is achieved.

Ken Rheingans writes: “[AI Agents] are teams of AI-powered virtual assistants that collaborate to solve complex problems. Unlike traditional AI systems that generate a single output based on a given prompt, AI Agents work together, sharing goals and making collective decisions to tackle tasks more effectively. This collaborative approach allows for more sophisticated interactions and decision-making processes, ultimately leading to improved efficiency and significantly more accurate results across various applications. Agentic Workflows advance the concept of AI Agents by incorporating iterative refinement and feedback mechanisms. In an Agentic Workflow, AI Agents can generate drafts, receive guidance to improve those drafts, and iterate on their output. This process can lead to more accurate and refined results, as the AI Agents receive specific feedback and have the opportunity to adjust within the parameters of the assigned task. This improved accuracy is the amazing part where good LLM outputs become superhuman great outputs.”

Margo Poda writes: “Enterprise-wide use cases require more than just well-thought-out responses — enterprises need AI agents that can reliably manage complex goals and workflows. This demand has driven the emergence of agentic capabilities like autonomous goal-setting, reasoning, decision-making, robust language understanding, and the ability to connect with enterprise systems using plugins. These agentic capabilities unlock a new generation of enterprise AI solutions — including AI copilots. These tools are being designed to operate without constant human oversight across varied domains. In this way, agentic systems interpret instructions more accurately, set subgoals to accomplish multi-step tasks, and make adaptive choices adjusting to real-time developments, enabling reliable automation of convoluted business objectives.”

Economist: “There is a way…to make large language models (LLMs) perform such complex jobs: make them work together. Researchers are experimenting with teams of LLMs—known as multi-agent systems (MAS)—that can assign each other tasks, build on each other’s work or deliberate over a problem in order to find a solution that any one, on its own, would have been unable to find. And all without the need for a human to direct them at every step. Teams also demonstrate the kinds of reasoning and mathematical skills that are usually beyond stand-alone AI models. And they could be less prone to generating inaccurate or false information.”

Thinks 1255

Mint: “India’s welfare delivery model stands at a crossroads today. The public debate on poverty tends to centre on the poverty line and ways to measure it accurately. But we need to start paying more attention to how poor beneficiaries get identified. Even with a universally-agreed definition of poverty, governments will still need granular data on household characteristics to be able to reach poor households. They will also need to find a way to update such data regularly, so that a household that escapes poverty is eased out of the social security net, while one that becomes poor is included. Without a reliable and dynamic database, governments will find it hard to reach the poorest of households in need of state support. They will have to either rely on extra-official agents to help identify the poorest lot, or devise quasi-universal schemes to cut down exclusion errors. After a decade of rapid progress in welfare delivery, India may be headed back to the pre-SECC era.”

WSJ: “Did your mom ever suggest a warm glass of milk to help you sleep? An emerging field of research called chrononutrition indicates that choosing the right foods and meal times may improve our sleep. Some key findings: Eat dinner early. Keep consistent schedules. And, yes, drink milk. You already know that fruits, veggies and lean protein are good for your health. But they can boost your sleep, too. These foods are the basis for the Mediterranean diet, which research shows may improve sleep quality, reduce sleep disturbances and boost sleep efficiency—the amount of time you spend asleep when you are in bed.”

The Generalist: “Great cultures stem from the founder’s personality. The result is that an Elon Musk company will differ from one founded by Jeff Bezos simply because of their differing personalities and perspectives. Entrepreneurs should look to legendary firms for inspiration but be wary of adopting their approaches wholesale. For a culture to be authentic, it has to connect to the people driving it. Use rituals to enforce your values. It is not enough to simply state your company’s principles. You must find ways to embody them through repeated rituals. For example, Front champions its culture of “transparency.” One ritual that puts this principle into practice is for team members to keep their calendars public. Find small ritualistic behaviors that reinforce the culture you want.”

Rahul Matthan: “Karthik Muralidharan’s tome, Accelerating India’s Development, [is] in many ways, is a remarkable book, not just because of its size (at 800 pages, it could easily do duty as a doorstop), but because of how it has been written. It’s neatly organized into bite-sized essays that are easy to digest, with each chapter building on those before it to collectively contribute to the grand argument. Most importantly, unlike so many books of its ilk, instead of just focusing on what is wrong with the Indian state, it offers implementable suggestions as to how to make it better. The starting premise of the book is that the last time we made any “systematic investments into the institutional foundations of the Indian state” was in 1950. Since then, all we have done is increase our expectations of what the state must provide us without making necessary investments in its capacity to deliver. One of the reasons for this, Karthik argues, is that Indian citizens had universal adult franchise right from the country’s birth, unlike those of other nations. Where other countries pursued development at the cost of initially disenfranchised interest groups (women, minorities and the like), Indian politicians had to appease everyone and as a result could take no short-cuts. This is why as powerful as universal adult franchise has been for democracy, it has affected the pace of our development.”

WSJ: “Stock photographers who survived the disruptive advent of digital cameras and online sales are bracing themselves for the next great tech shock: generative AI. “The stock photography industry is going away,” said Connecticut-based photographer Tony Northrup. “AI is ending it for the remaining photographers who figured out how to stay profitable.” Photographers’ concerns highlight a growing unease within the wider commercial creative industries that AI will wipe out jobs that until now have relied on artistic talent and decades of experience. Industries such as marketing, publishing, music and news have long relied on stock photography to create, illustrate or promote their products for less cost than commissioning photos would require. AI’s new capability to generate realistic images from simple text prompts is now giving stock clients an affordable, fast alternative that comes with greater control of the final image.”

How Agentic AI will Transform Digital Marketing (Part 3)

Benedict Evans

Here are a few slides from a Benedict Evans presentation from December 2023:

 

In a recent essay (April 2024), Benedict Evans writes: “We’ve had ChatGPT for 18 months, but what’s it for? What are the use-cases? Why isn’t it useful for everyone, right now? Do Large Language Models become universal tools that can do ‘any’ task, or do we wrap them in single-purpose apps, and build thousands of new companies around that?… We would still have an orders of magnitude change in how much can be automated, and how many use-cases can be found for LLMs, but they still need to be found and built one by one. The change would be that these new use-cases would be things that are still automated one-at-a-time, but that could not have been automated before, or that would have needed far more software (and capital) to automate. That would make LLMs the new SQL, not the new HAL9000.”

Thinks 1254

Michaeleen Doucleff: “To make cognitively demanding tasks a habit, try to do them every day at the same time and in the same place. Add a ritual before you start, such as turning off your phone and launching an app to block distracting websites. “You’ll teach yourself that mental exertion pays off under these certain conditions,” Botvinick says. After a few weeks, concentrating deeply won’t just feel easier; it will actually be easier.”

FT: “Mike Brearley, once at the helm of a very successful England cricket side, is now a psychoanalyst. He argues we each have a team of internal players, who we need to coach so we can use all their skills for tip-top performance — and find balance between them for a happy existence. “We all have an indulgent side, a playful side, a serious side, a work ethic, a superego or a harsh conscience,” he said in a recent interview with Cambridge university’s alumni magazine…Instead of falling out with ourselves and indulging in the equivalent of locker room fisticuffs, his advice, in a book published last year, was that “captaining ourselves, like captaining a team, requires a willingness to allow thoughts and feelings their space”. He suggests “nudging rather than forcing” these parts of ourselves into being more effective.”

Arnold Kling: “In profit-seeking businesses, a company that gets too heavily bureaucratic will eventually lose money and have to cut back or go bankrupt. That provides a check on bureaucracy. But government interferes with this process by creating compliance requirements. These requirements force businesses to expand bureaucracy, and they provide a barrier to entry preventing new firms from coming in and competing on the basis of lower overhead. You cannot execute a lean startup in an industry that is heavily regulated.”

WSJ: “[Cal] Newport, 41, says we can accomplish more by shedding the overload. He calls his solution “slow productivity”—and has a book by the same name—a way for high achievers to say yes to fewer things, do them better and even slack off in strategic doses. Top-notch quality is the goal, and frenetic activity the enemy.  This, he told me, is the thing that can save our jobs from AI and layoffs, and even make shareholders happy…One mistake we make, Newport says, is taking on too many projects, then getting bogged down in the administrative overload—talking about the work, coordinating with others—that each requires. Work becomes a string of planning meetings, waiting on someone from another department to give us a go-ahead. Newport recommends giving priority to a couple projects, then bumping the others to a waiting list in order of importance. Make that list public, say, in a Google doc you share with bosses and colleagues. “

Dev Ittycheria: “The real sophisticated [AI] apps will be using real-time data, being able to make real-time decisions on real-time events. Maybe something’s happening in the stock market, maybe it’s time to buy or sell, or it’s time to hedge. I think that’s where we will start seeing much more sophisticated apps, where you can embed real-time data along with all the reasoning.”

How Agentic AI will Transform Digital Marketing (Part 2)

Industry Revolutions

ChatGPT wrote about some historical examples of industry transformations and their impact on both incumbents and disruptors.

  1. The Industrial Revolution (Late 18th to Early 19th Century)
  • Transformation: The introduction of mechanized production transformed agriculture and textile manufacturing in Europe and the U.S., transitioning from manual labor to machines.
  • Impact on Incumbents: Traditional craftsmen and artisans found it challenging to compete with the efficiency and scalability of machine production. Many were either forced out of business or had to adapt to new manufacturing processes.
  • Impact on Disruptors: Innovators who adopted and improved upon industrial technologies—like Richard Arkwright with his water frame—were able to build large-scale factories that dominated industries. This period also saw the rise of industrial magnates and a shift in the workforce from rural to urban settings.
  1. The Automotive Industry (Early 20th Century)
  • Transformation: The mass production techniques pioneered by Henry Ford made automobiles affordable and accessible to a large segment of the population, which was previously dominated by carriage and locomotive manufacturers.
  • Impact on Incumbents: Many traditional carriage and harness makers went out of business or significantly downsized, unable to compete with the cost and functionality of automobiles.
  • Impact on Disruptors: Ford and other early automobile companies like General Motors rapidly expanded, fundamentally changing transportation, city planning, and consumer culture.
  1. The Information Technology Revolution (Late 20th Century)
  • Transformation: The advent of personal computing and later the internet changed how businesses operate, how information is processed, and how products are marketed.
  • Impact on Incumbents: Companies that failed to adapt to new IT capabilities (like Kodak with digital photography or Blockbuster with video streaming) struggled or failed.
  • Impact on Disruptors: Companies such as Apple in personal computing, Amazon in e-commerce, and Google in online search and advertising leveraged new technologies to create dominant new economic paradigms and business models.
  1. Renewable Energy Shift (21st Century)
  • Transformation: Growing environmental concerns and technological advances have driven a shift from fossil fuels to renewable energy sources such as solar and wind.
  • Impact on Incumbents: Traditional energy companies face regulatory and market pressure to transition to or incorporate renewables into their energy mix, with varying degrees of resistance and adaptation.
  • Impact on Disruptors: New entrants like Tesla in electric vehicles and NextEra in wind energy have capitalized on these shifts, challenging established players and often leading the market.
  1. Digital Streaming and Entertainment (Early 21st Century)
  • Transformation: Digital streaming technologies have transformed media consumption, moving from physical and broadcast media to on-demand streaming.
  • Impact on Incumbents: Media companies reliant on traditional broadcasting and cable television have had to pivot significantly or partner with tech companies to survive.
  • Impact on Disruptors: Platforms like Netflix, Spotify, and YouTube have grown from niche players to major industry leaders, setting new standards for content distribution and consumption.

These examples illustrate how technological innovations and shifts in consumer preferences have historically led to significant industry transformations. They also highlight the recurring theme of “creative destruction,” where new technologies disrupt existing market structures, often leading to the decline of incumbents and the rise of new leaders. This pattern is likely to be reflected in how AI will reshape industries in the coming years.

[Rajesh] If we reflect on our lives today compared to just two or three decades ago, the magnitude of change is staggering — the way we consume news and information (Google Search and social platforms like Twitter/X, Instagram, Facebook), how we entertain ourselves (Netflix and Amazon Prime), how we shop (Amazon and dozens of shopping sites), how we communicate (WhatsApp), how we network (LinkedIn). What’s remarkable is that all these transformative changes have occurred within the span of just a single generation. The pace of innovation shows no signs of slowing down. In the realm of artificial intelligence, this pace is even more accelerated. What once took a generation now transpires in a year, if not months or even weeks, underscoring the transformative era we live in.

Thinks 1253

Jaspreet Bindra: “Agents will be the next big thing in artificial intelligence…Agents would also create the next class of devices for the post-smartphone era, like Rabbit R1 and AI Pin, both of which were unveiled recently. They use GenAI models as their operating system (OS), natural spoken language as their user interface (UI), and, importantly, have rudimentary agents instead of apps. So, for example, you can call an Uber, order food on Doordash or play Spotify by just telling your Rabbit R1 to do so. A Large Action Model (LAM), which is built on LLMs, functions as Rabbit’s OS to make it your personal voice assistant. The LAM OS uses its long-term memory of you to translate your requests into actionable steps and responses; it comprehends what apps and services you use daily. The LAM can learn to see and act in the world like humans do. It is still early days, but the app-led devices of today will likely give way to new agent-led devices.”

Peggy Noonan: “Even though it isn’t new, uglification is rising and spreading as an artistic attitude, and it can’t be good for us. Because it speaks of self-hatred, and a society that hates itself, and hates life, won’t last. Because it gives those who are young nothing to love and feel soft about. Because we need beauty to keep our morale up.”

WSJ: “Renewable electricity is growing fast. The trouble is, it can’t keep up with growing power demand. In the U.S., the new driver is energy-guzzling artificial intelligence. Demand was already on the rise to power electric vehicles, heat pumps and other devices designed to reduce fossil fuel use. In the developing world, the boom is driven by industrialization and basics like lights and air conditioning. That means more fossil fuels, including coal, the worst emissions offender. “The reality is we can keep adding renewables until we’re blue in the face and it won’t be enough,” said Sumant Sinha, chief executive of ReNew, one of India’s biggest renewable energy companies.”

FT: “In a new book, Making Sense of Chaos, the complexity scientist Doyne Farmer points out that both Moore’s Law and Wright’s Law provide a good basis for forecasting the costs of different technologies. Both nicely describe the patterns that we see in the data. But which one is closer to identifying the underlying causes of these patterns? Moore’s Law suggests that products get cheaper over time, and because they are cheaper they then are demanded and produced in larger quantities. Wright’s Law suggests that rather than falling costs spurring production, it’s mass production that causes costs to fall. And therein lies the missed opportunity. We acted as though Moore’s Law governed the cost of photovoltaics. While there were of course subsidies for solar PV in countries such as Germany, the default view was that it was too expensive to be much use as a large-scale power source, so we should wait and hope that it would eventually become cheap. If instead we had looked through the lens of Wright’s Law, governments should have been falling over themselves to buy or otherwise subsidise expensive solar PV, because the more we bought, the faster the price would fall. PV is now so cheap that the question is moot. Yet if we had acted more boldly 40 years ago, solar PV might have been cheap enough to put fossil fuels out of business at the turn of the millennium.”

Harish Damodaran: “The political economy of India has changed considerably to transcend the simple binaries of amir-garib. The old expropriate-and-redistribute model has lost its political viability. The withdrawn 2014 land acquisition act amendments and the 2016 demonetisation were probably the last experiments at expropriation. Income and wealth inequality may have to be addressed through policies focusing more on job generation, universal access to quality education, skill development and progressive taxation than radical redistribution.”