Published June 28-July 5, 2-2025
1
State of News
Co-created with AI.
The news media industry stands at a perilous crossroads, grappling with an existential crisis that has fundamentally undermined the economic foundations upon which journalism has thrived for generations. Once commanding both reader attention and advertiser dollars, traditional publishers now face a perfect storm of declining revenues, eroding trust, and the twin scourges of platform dependency and engagement drought. The brutal mathematics are inescapable: traditional advertising revenues have plummeted by over 70% in the past two decades, whilst digital transformation has created a cruel paradox—more readers than ever before, yet fewer willing to pay for quality journalism.
The rise of social media platforms has reduced news consumption to fleeting moments between entertainment content, whilst search engines and aggregators capture the lion’s share of advertising revenue whilst contributing nothing to content creation costs. Publishers find themselves competing not just with each other, but with an infinite stream of algorithmic feeds designed to maximise engagement at any cost. Meanwhile, programmatic advertising models built on pageviews and clicks have been systematically hollowed out by Google and Meta’s dominance, leaving publishers fighting for scraps in an attention economy that rewards sensationalism over substance.
The industry’s response has been largely tactical and increasingly desperate. Subscription models promise salvation but convert only a small fraction of readers, creating unsustainable dependency on dwindling loyal audiences. Paywalls frustrate occasional readers whilst failing to generate sufficient revenue. Email newsletters, initially seen as a hopeful channel for direct reader engagement, often suffer from poor personalisation and anaemic open rates—becoming just another voice lost in the inbox noise. The “pivot to digital” promised transformation but delivered fragmentation, scattering readers across multiple touchpoints whilst making it nearly impossible to build the consistent, habitual engagement that premium journalism requires.
Perhaps most damaging has been the complete loss of control over audience relationships. Content lives hostage on third-party platforms that can change algorithms without warning. Reader attention is systematically siphoned off by social feeds and aggregators that profit from journalism without contributing to its costs. With AI-generated summaries growing in popularity, even organic traffic—the last vestige of direct publisher-reader connection—is shrinking rapidly. Publishers are left fighting for survival in a world where the web no longer works in their favour, whilst regulatory discussions about “link taxes” and content licensing fees offer little practical relief.
The problem isn’t merely economic—it’s existential. News organisations have ceded their most valuable asset: direct reader relationships. This intermediation has reduced news consumption to decontextualised snippets, undermining the comprehensive understanding that quality journalism aims to provide whilst simultaneously destroying the advertising economics that funded serious reporting for over a century.
Yet within this crisis lies an unprecedented opportunity for renaissance through two revolutionary innovations: NeoMails and NeoN. These technologies promise not just survival, but genuine resurgence—a chance for media companies to reclaim their audience relationships, regain control of distribution, and unlock entirely new revenue streams from attention they already command.
NeoMails represent a new breed of interactive, AMP-powered emails that eliminate the friction of clickthroughs by bringing the complete news experience—articles, real-time updates, interactive polls—directly into the email itself. News can now be consumed, updated dynamically upon opening, and personalised at the moment of engagement rather than being fixed when sent. When combined with “Magnets” like daily puzzles, brain teasers, and interactive polls, NeoMails transform inboxes into engagement hotspots, encouraging habit loops that increase daily opens and create the consistent touchpoints that premium journalism desperately needs.
NeoN provides the crucial monetisation layer through authenticated identity and precision targeting, transforming publisher emails into premium advertising real estate that respects reader privacy whilst delivering high-value, contextually relevant advertisements. This isn’t about surveillance capitalism—it’s about zero-click, zero-waste monetisation, where attention is monetised ethically and efficiently without sending readers away to external sites where they’re immediately lost to competing content.
This represents not mere reinvention but genuine redemption—the chance for news media to rewrite its future by embracing technologies that restore economic viability whilst enhancing rather than compromising editorial excellence. The inbox, once overlooked and underleveraged, is becoming the next great frontier for news engagement and profitability, offering publishers their most promising path to renaissance in generations.
2
Overview
I asked the AIs (Claude and ChatGPT) for a historical overview of the new media industry.
The news media industry represents one of the most complex and rapidly evolving sectors in the global economy, encompassing multiple platforms, distribution channels, and business models that have undergone dramatic transformation over the past century. What began as a relatively stable ecosystem dominated by a few powerful, centralised institutions controlling mass distribution has evolved into a fragmented, fast-moving landscape influenced by technology platforms, user-generated content, algorithmic curation, and artificial intelligence. Understanding this landscape requires examining each segment’s evolution, current challenges, and the intricate interdependencies that shape how information flows to audiences worldwide.
Print Media: The Foundation Under Siege
Print media, comprising newspapers, magazines, journals, and tabloids, formed the bedrock of journalism for over 300 years, establishing the fundamental practices, ethical standards, and business models that defined the industry. Traditional newspapers operated on a sophisticated dual revenue model: circulation income from readers who valued curated, quality journalism, and advertising revenue from local and national businesses seeking to reach engaged, demographically defined audiences.
The economics were once extraordinarily compelling: newspapers enjoyed natural monopolies in their geographic markets, with morning and evening editions creating multiple daily touchpoints with readers. Classified advertising provided particularly lucrative revenue streams, with property, automotive, and employment sections generating substantial margins. Major metropolitan dailies and regional papers commanded substantial social and political influence whilst generating healthy profit margins that funded extensive newsroom operations, foreign bureaus, and investigative journalism.
Magazines carved out specialised niches with even more targeted demographics, from weekly news publications to lifestyle publications targeting specific interests, professions, and income brackets. The magazine model proved particularly effective for luxury brands and B2B advertisers seeking to reach affluent, engaged audiences willing to pay premium prices for quality content.
However, the digital revolution has systematically devastated print economics across all categories. Newspaper circulation has declined since 2000, with many historic titles either closing entirely or dramatically reducing their print operations. Local and regional newspapers have been particularly hard hit, with many areas becoming “news deserts” lacking dedicated local coverage.
The classified advertising market—once worth billions annually—has largely migrated to digital platforms, which offer superior search functionality, real-time updates, and lower costs for advertisers. Display advertising rates have plummeted as advertisers shifted budgets to digital channels offering better targeting, measurement capabilities, and lower costs per impression.
Print’s challenges extend beyond economics to fundamental operational realities: printing and distribution costs remain largely fixed whilst revenues decline precipitously, creating unsustainable cost structures that force painful editorial cuts. The tactile reading experience that once differentiated print—quality paper, sophisticated layout, permanent availability—has been largely replicated by high-quality digital devices and e-readers, eroding print’s unique value proposition for all but the most devoted readers.
Radio News: The Resilient Audio Medium
Radio has demonstrated remarkable resilience despite successive waves of technological disruption, successfully adapting from AM to FM to digital broadcasting whilst maintaining significant audience reach across diverse demographics. Radio’s enduring strengths lie in its fundamental accessibility, immediacy, and unique ability to provide companionship during daily activities like commuting, working, exercising, and household tasks. The medium’s intimacy—created through direct presenter-to-listener communication—builds personal relationships that television and digital media struggle to replicate. Talk radio has carved out particularly loyal audiences, and regional talk stations building substantial followings through personality-driven programming, phone-in formats that create community engagement, and real-time response to breaking news events.
News radio excels during crisis situations, providing continuous coverage when visual media becomes impractical or unavailable. The medium’s low bandwidth requirements ensure accessibility during emergencies when internet and television services may be compromised. Drive-time news bulletins remain crucial for many commuters, whilst hourly updates throughout the day provide consistent news consumption touchpoints.
However, radio faces mounting pressures from multiple directions. Streaming services provide personalised audio experiences without advertising interruptions, appealing particularly to younger demographics who prioritise on-demand consumption over scheduled programming. Podcasting has emerged as a particular threat, offering the intimacy and personality-driven content that radio pioneered but with complete listener control over timing and topic selection.
Digital audio advertising, whilst growing rapidly, often commands lower rates than traditional radio spots due to increased inventory and more precise targeting that reduces premium positioning.
Smart speakers and voice assistants have created new audio consumption patterns that both threaten and offer opportunities for radio. Whilst listeners can easily request specific music or podcasts, radio stations that optimize for voice search and integrate with smart speaker ecosystems can reach new audiences. However, this requires technical investments and content adaptation that strain traditional radio business models.
Television News: The Dominant Medium in Transition
Television remains the dominant news medium for many demographics, particularly older audiences. Television news benefits from unparalleled visual storytelling capabilities, authoritative presentation standards, and scheduled programming that creates appointment viewing for major events, breaking news, and regular analysis programmes.
The medium’s substantial production values—professional anchors, experienced reporters, sophisticated graphics packages, and live coverage capabilities from multiple locations—establish credibility and authority that other platforms struggle to match. Breaking news coverage remains television’s greatest competitive advantage, with audiences consistently turning to TV during major events, natural disasters, political crises, and elections for comprehensive, real-time information delivered by recognisable, trusted presenters.
Television news also benefits from regulatory frameworks that ensure balanced coverage and editorial standards. These requirements, whilst sometimes constraining, create viewer trust that purely commercial or unregulated platforms often lack. The shared viewing experience of major news events—elections, royal occasions, sporting events—continues to create national conversations that fragmented digital consumption cannot replicate.
Yet television faces existential challenges from fundamental changes in viewing behaviour and technological disruption. Younger audiences increasingly consume news through social media platforms, YouTube channels, and digital-native publications rather than scheduled broadcasts, viewing traditional television news as slow, inflexible, and less relevant to their interests and lifestyles.
The shift to streaming services and on-demand viewing has fundamentally disrupted television’s appointment viewing model. Whilst news programmes are available through catch-up services and streaming platforms, they compete with vast libraries of entertainment content for attention. Traditional television advertising faces severe pressure from digital alternatives offering superior targeting capabilities, measurement precision, and often lower costs, whilst television news production costs remain substantial due to staffing, equipment, and distribution requirements.
The fragmentation of viewing across multiple platforms—terrestrial, satellite, cable, streaming, and mobile—makes it increasingly difficult for television news to maintain the mass simultaneous audiences that once defined the medium’s cultural and political power. Live viewing figures continue declining across most demographics, whilst time-shifted viewing often involves advertisement skipping that undermines advertising revenue models.
Internet News: The Transformation Catalyst
The internet fundamentally disrupted every aspect of news media, initially promising democratisation, global reach, and expanded opportunities for journalism whilst ultimately creating winner-take-all dynamics that have systematically disadvantaged traditional publishers. Early internet adoption saw newspapers and broadcasters simply republishing print content online, failing to recognise the medium’s unique characteristics, opportunities, and threats.
Digital-native publications emerged with internet-first strategies, emphasising social media sharing, search engine optimisation, viral content creation, and reader engagement over traditional journalistic values like comprehensiveness, balance, and institutional authority. These new entrants demonstrated fundamentally different approaches to online audience building and engagement whilst traditional publishers struggled to monetise their digital audiences effectively.
The internet’s global reach eliminated geographic constraints that had protected local media monopolies, intensifying competition as local newspapers found themselves competing with international publications, specialist blogs, and social media content for reader attention. Search engine optimisation became crucial for content discovery, yet publishers found themselves increasingly dependent on Google’s algorithms for traffic whilst receiving minimal revenue from the billions of advertising pounds flowing through Google’s advertising platforms.
Programmatic advertising promised efficient, automated ad buying but systematically commoditised publisher inventory, driving down advertising rates whilst enabling advertisers to target audiences across multiple sites rather than associating with specific publications. This shift fundamentally undermined the premium positioning that quality publications once commanded in advertising markets, reducing journalism to a commodity competing primarily on price rather than quality or brand association.
The internet also enabled new forms of journalism—live blogging, multimedia storytelling, reader comments and interaction, real-time fact-checking—that enhanced news consumption experiences. However, these innovations required new skills, technologies, and editorial processes that many traditional publishers were slow to adopt, allowing digital-native competitors to establish market positions that became increasingly difficult to challenge.
Website analytics and user behaviour tracking provided unprecedented insights into reader preferences, enabling content optimisation and personalisation that improved engagement metrics. However, this data also revealed uncomfortable truths about news consumption: readers often engaged with headlines without reading full articles, shared content without consuming it, and preferred entertainment or lifestyle content over serious journalism, creating editorial tensions between audience engagement and journalistic mission.
Mobile News: The Ubiquitous Platform Revolution
Mobile devices have fundamentally transformed news consumption patterns, becoming the primary platform for news access across most demographics worldwide. Smartphones enable constant connectivity and immediate access to breaking news, creating audience expectations for real-time updates, push notifications, and instant information gratification that traditional media struggle to fulfil consistently without overwhelming readers.
Mobile consumption patterns strongly favour brevity, visual content, and easily digestible formats over lengthy articles or complex analysis, systematically influencing editorial decisions across the industry. The constraints of small screens, touch interfaces, and often hurried consumption contexts have pushed news towards shorter paragraphs, bullet points, infographics, and video content that work effectively on mobile devices.
Push notifications have become crucial for breaking news distribution and audience retention, yet overuse consistently leads to notification fatigue and opt-outs that progressively reduce publishers’ direct reach to audiences. Successful mobile news strategies require careful balance between staying top-of-mind and avoiding reader annoyance, with many publishers implementing sophisticated notification strategies that segment audiences and personalise alert frequency.
The mobile advertising market, whilst substantial and growing, remains dominated by Google and Meta’s platforms, leaving publishers competing for a relatively small fraction of mobile advertising revenue. Mobile advertising formats—banner ads, interstitials, native ads—often generate lower revenue per impression than desktop advertising whilst potentially creating worse user experiences that drive reader abandonment.
Mobile page loading speeds critically affect both user experience and search engine rankings, requiring technical investments in content delivery networks, and optimised coding that strain publishers’ technical resources whilst delivering unclear direct returns. The mobile-first indexing approaches used by search engines mean that mobile optimization now determines overall search visibility rather than being a secondary consideration.
Mobile-first publications have built successful businesses specifically around mobile-optimised content formats, demonstrating that publishers must fundamentally rethink content creation, presentation, and distribution for mobile consumption rather than simply adapting desktop experiences for smaller screens.
Social Media Platforms: The Distribution Gatekeepers
Social media platforms have emerged as crucial news distribution channels whilst simultaneously undermining traditional publishers’ business models and editorial control. Facebook, Twitter/X, Instagram, TikTok, LinkedIn, and messaging platforms like WhatsApp drive substantial traffic to news sites but control algorithmic distribution mechanisms that can change without warning, making publishers dependent on platforms that may prioritise user engagement over news consumption quality.
Facebook’s influence on news distribution cannot be overstated—the platform’s News Feed algorithm determines what news content billions of users see daily, with algorithm changes capable of dramatically impacting publisher traffic and revenue overnight. The platform’s various strategic shifts—from favouring publisher content to prioritising posts from friends and family, from emphasising video content to reducing news visibility—have repeatedly disrupted publisher strategies and forced costly pivots.
The infamous “pivot to video” encouraged publishers to invest heavily in video content production based on Facebook’s promotion of video posts and inflated engagement metrics, only for publishers to later discover that view counts were significantly overstated. This led to widespread layoffs across digital media companies and demonstrated the risks of platform dependency for content strategy decisions.
Twitter/X serves as a crucial platform for breaking news distribution, real-time commentary, and journalist-audience interaction, but recent ownership changes and policy modifications have created uncertainty about the platform’s future role in news distribution. The platform’s character limits favour brevity and rapid-fire updates over comprehensive reporting, influencing how news is packaged and consumed.
Instagram and TikTok have emerged as significant news sources for younger demographics, with visual storytelling formats and short-form video content providing news updates in highly engaging formats that traditional media struggle to replicate effectively. However, these platforms’ algorithms and format constraints incentivise entertaining rather than comprehensive coverage, whilst their recommendation systems may amplify sensational or polarising content.
LinkedIn has become increasingly important for business and professional news distribution, whilst platforms like Reddit enable community-driven news curation and discussion that can significantly influence news visibility and interpretation. The rise of “dark social”—news sharing through private messaging apps like WhatsApp, Telegram, and direct messages—makes it increasingly difficult for publishers to track content distribution and engagement whilst providing no direct monetisation opportunities.
Social platforms typically capture the majority of advertising revenue generated by news content shared on their platforms, whilst publishers bear all content creation costs and face risks of misinformation attribution when their content is shared out of context or without proper sourcing information.
Video and YouTube: The Visual Revolution
Video content has become central to digital news consumption, with YouTube emerging as a major news platform alongside traditional broadcasters, fundamentally changing how audiences discover, consume, and engage with news content. The platform hosts everything from traditional news organisation channels to independent creators, political commentators, and citizen journalists who often build larger, more engaged followings than established television programmes.
YouTube’s monetisation model allows content creators to earn revenue directly from advertising, though rates vary significantly based on audience demographics, content categories, and algorithmic promotion, whilst platform policy changes can dramatically impact creator earnings without warning. The platform’s recommendation algorithm tends to favour engaging, often polarising content that generates strong viewer reactions, creating incentives for sensational coverage that may conflict with traditional journalistic standards and ethical guidelines.
Traditional news organisations have invested heavily in video production specifically for digital platforms, creating dedicated YouTube channels, social media video content, and live streaming capabilities. However, they often struggle to achieve the view counts necessary for substantial revenue generation, whilst competing with independent creators who may have lower production costs and more provocative content strategies.
The costs of quality video production—professional equipment, editing software, hosting infrastructure, and skilled personnel—remain substantial, whilst advertising revenue must typically be shared with platform providers rather than flowing entirely to publishers. Live streaming capabilities through YouTube Live, Facebook Live, Instagram Live, and Twitter Spaces have enabled real-time news coverage and audience interaction, but these often reach smaller audiences than traditional television whilst generating minimal direct revenue.
Independent news creators on YouTube have demonstrated the potential for alternative journalism models, and various investigative journalists building substantial audiences and revenue streams outside traditional media structures. However, these creators face the same platform dependency risks as traditional publishers whilst often lacking the resources for comprehensive newsgathering and fact-checking.
Search Engines and Aggregators: The Traffic Controllers
Google dominates news discovery through search results and Google News, directing substantial traffic to publishers whilst capturing the vast majority of search advertising revenue that publishers once earned directly. Google’s Featured Snippets, Knowledge Panels, and AI-powered answer boxes increasingly provide enough information to satisfy user queries without requiring clicks to publisher sites, systematically reducing traffic and revenue opportunities for content creators.
Google News and similar aggregation services create convenient news consumption experiences for readers whilst commoditising publisher content. These platforms often display headlines, snippets, and key information without requiring clicks to original sources, enabling readers to stay informed without visiting publisher sites, viewing their advertising, or contributing to their revenue streams.
The relationship between publishers and search engines remains fundamentally contentious, with ongoing debates about “link taxes,” revenue sharing arrangements, and fair compensation that have led to legislative efforts in Australia, France, Canada, and other markets. Publishers argue that search engines profit enormously from indexing and displaying their content without adequate compensation, whilst search engines contend that they provide valuable traffic referrals that publishers should monetise independently.
However, publishers remain critically dependent on search platforms for content discovery, creating complex dependencies that are difficult to resolve through purely adversarial approaches. Search engine optimisation has become essential for publisher visibility, requiring significant technical expertise and content strategy adjustments, yet algorithm changes can dramatically impact traffic and revenue overnight, creating planning uncertainty that makes business forecasting challenging.
Alternative search engines like Bing, DuckDuckGo, and Apple’s search initiatives provide some diversification opportunities, but Google’s market dominance means that most publishers must optimise primarily for Google’s algorithms and policies regardless of philosophical or business concerns about platform dependency.
News Aggregators and Recommendation Engines: The Curation Layer
Beyond search engines, dedicated news aggregators have created additional layers between publishers and audiences, often driving substantial traffic whilst further commoditising content. These platforms range from algorithm-driven services to human-curated collections, each creating different challenges and opportunities for publishers.
Apple News provides a premium reading experience with sophisticated typography and layout whilst requiring publishers to either share advertising revenue or pay for premium placement. The platform reaches substantial audiences but offers limited brand recognition for publishers, with readers often consuming content without strong awareness of the original source.
Various apps create magazine-like reading experiences that aggregate content from multiple sources, often reformatting articles for consistent presentation that may obscure publisher branding whilst providing convenient consumption experiences that readers value.
Social aggregation platforms like Reddit enable community-driven content curation and discussion that can significantly influence news story visibility and interpretation. However, these platforms’ discussion-focused formats often emphasise reader commentary over original reporting, potentially devaluing professional journalism whilst amplifying amateur analysis.
The rise of personalised news feeds powered by machine learning algorithms has created increasingly individualised news consumption experiences that may contribute to information filter bubbles and echo chambers, whilst making it difficult for publishers to predict or influence content distribution patterns.
Podcasting: The Audio Renaissance
Podcasting has emerged as a significant and rapidly growing news medium, offering intimate, in-depth coverage that appeals to engaged audiences willing to invest substantial time in news consumption. News podcasts and independent offerings have built substantial, loyal audiences that often exceed traditional radio programme listenership.
The podcast medium’s unique characteristics—on-demand consumption, personal device listening, and often lengthy format—enable deeper exploration of complex topics than traditional broadcast formats allow. Successful news podcasts often combine breaking news updates with analytical discussion, expert interviews, and narrative storytelling that creates more comprehensive understanding than headline-based news consumption.
Podcast advertising rates frequently exceed other digital formats due to host-read endorsements, engaged audiences with higher attention levels, and demographic targeting capabilities that appeal to premium advertisers. However, podcast production requires different skills and resources than traditional journalism—audio editing, narrative structuring, and presentation techniques that many text-focused journalists must learn separately.
Podcast discoverability remains challenging without major platform promotion or existing audience bases, whilst the medium’s growth has led to increased competition for listener attention. The rise of exclusive podcast networks and platform-specific deals—such as Spotify’s acquisitions of Joe Rogan, The Ringer, and other major podcasters—has created new competitive dynamics that traditional news organisations are still learning to navigate effectively.
Streaming Services and On-Demand Platforms: The Entertainment Crossover
Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Disney+, Apple TV+, and other streaming services have begun investing in news and documentary content, creating new competitive pressures for traditional news organisations whilst blurring the lines between news and entertainment consumption. These platforms’ subscription models, global reach, and substantial content budgets enable documentary and investigative content investments that traditional publishers struggle to match.
Streaming services’ algorithmic recommendation systems and binge-watching cultural expectations have influenced audience expectations for news consumption, with some viewers seeking more narrative, documentary-style news content rather than traditional daily news formats. This has contributed to the success of investigative podcasts, documentary series, and long-form journalism that provides comprehensive exploration of complex topics.
However, most streaming services continue viewing news as a small component of their broader entertainment content strategies rather than a core focus area, limiting their direct impact on daily news consumption patterns whilst potentially creating new opportunities for news organisations to develop premium content for streaming distribution.
Artificial Intelligence: The Emerging Disruptor
AI represents the latest and potentially most transformative disruption to news media, with implications spanning content creation, distribution, curation, and consumption patterns. AI-powered tools are simultaneously threatening traditional publisher business models whilst creating new opportunities for content creation and audience engagement.
AI-powered news summarisation tools like ChatGPT and Claude, and specialised services like Perplexity provide readers with synthesised information compiled from multiple sources without requiring visits to original publisher sites. These tools can answer complex questions, provide context and analysis, and create comprehensive briefings on current events, potentially replacing the news consumption habits that currently drive publisher traffic and revenue.
Automated content generation capabilities raise fundamental questions about journalism’s value proposition when AI systems can produce basic news reports, earnings summaries, sports coverage, and even analysis pieces without human intervention. Publishers are increasingly experimenting with AI for content creation, fact-checking, personalisation, and workflow optimization, yet face concerns about accuracy, bias, editorial responsibility, and reader trust.
AI-powered recommendation systems now determine what news content millions of readers see daily, with algorithms prioritising engagement metrics over traditional editorial judgement. This may systematically amplify misinformation, polarising content, or sensational stories whilst de-emphasising complex, nuanced reporting that requires sustained reader attention but generates lower engagement metrics.
Voice assistants have become news sources for many users, typically providing brief audio summaries without attribution to original sources. This further commoditises news content whilst providing no revenue opportunities for publishers, even as readers receive value from professionally reported information.
The emergence of AI-generated deepfake videos, synthetic audio content, and sophisticated text generation has created new challenges for distinguishing authentic journalism from artificial content, potentially undermining reader trust in all news sources whilst creating new verification and fact-checking requirements that strain newsroom resources.
Alternative Platforms and Emerging Channels
TikTok has rapidly emerged as a significant news source for younger demographics, with short-form video content providing news updates, political commentary, and breaking news coverage in highly engaging, shareable formats. The platform’s algorithm and format constraints incentivise entertaining rather than comprehensive coverage, whilst TikTok’s Chinese ownership has created regulatory concerns in Western markets that may limit its long-term role in news distribution.
The platform’s unique content creation tools, effects, and cultural norms have enabled new forms of news presentation that traditional media organisations struggle to replicate effectively. However, TikTok’s emphasis on entertainment value over accuracy has contributed to misinformation spread, whilst the platform’s young user base may be developing news consumption habits that differ fundamentally from traditional journalism expectations.
Many social platforms have experimented with live news discussions, interviews, and community conversations that create new formats for news consumption and audience engagement. However, adoption of these platforms has been limited compared to established social media, whilst their live, unedited format creates potential risks for misinformation spread and editorial quality control.
Newsletter platforms like Substack and Ghost have enabled individual journalists to build direct subscription businesses, fundamentally challenging traditional employment models whilst creating new opportunities for independent journalism. Successful newsletter publishers and various specialist reporters have demonstrated viable business models based on direct reader support, though most independent newsletters reach relatively small audiences and generate modest revenues compared to traditional news organisation salaries.
Gaming platforms, virtual worlds, and emerging metaverse environments are beginning to host news content, discussions, and virtual events, particularly around topics relevant to gaming and technology communities. As digital native audiences mature and these platforms develop more sophisticated content capabilities, they may represent new frontiers for news distribution and audience engagement.
Creator-Led and Citizen Journalism: The Democratisation Wave
Independent journalists, citizen reporters, and content creators using smartphones, social media platforms, and blogging tools have fundamentally reshaped news creation and distribution, often providing coverage of events and perspectives that traditional media overlook or cannot access quickly.
Citizen journalism’s strengths include hyper-local coverage of community events, real-time reporting from breaking news scenes, authentic on-the-ground perspectives during crises or conflicts, and coverage of niche topics or communities that traditional media may not serve effectively. Social media platforms enable immediate publication and distribution without traditional gatekeepers, allowing important stories to reach global audiences within minutes of occurrence.
However, citizen journalism also presents significant challenges including lack of editorial oversight and fact-checking, potential for misinformation spread through well-intentioned but inaccurate reporting, inconsistent quality and reliability compared to professional journalism standards, and difficulty for audiences to assess credibility and bias of citizen-generated content.
The rise of creator-led journalism on platforms like YouTube, TikTok, and Substack has enabled new models of independent reporting that combine traditional journalism skills with direct audience relationships and alternative revenue streams. Some independent creators have built substantial audiences and influence that rival traditional news organisations, whilst maintaining editorial independence and specialised focus areas.
Regulatory and Policy Environment: The Governance Challenge
Government regulation increasingly shapes news media dynamics across multiple dimensions, creating complex compliance requirements that particularly burden smaller news organisations whilst potentially benefiting larger platforms with greater regulatory resources.
Data privacy regulations like GDPR, CCPA, and similar laws affect digital advertising models by limiting tracking capabilities and requiring consent mechanisms that reduce advertising effectiveness and revenue. Content moderation requirements imposed on social media platforms affect how news content is distributed and discovered, whilst platform liability laws influence what content is promoted or suppressed by algorithmic systems.
Antitrust investigations and regulatory actions targeting major technology platforms may reshape competitive dynamics in digital advertising, search, and social media distribution that fundamentally affect news publisher economics. However, regulatory solutions often lag significantly behind technological changes, creating extended periods of uncertainty for industry participants.
Public service broadcasting requirements in many countries create different competitive dynamics that affect commercial news organisations’ strategies and market positioning. International regulations around content blocking, data localisation, and platform liability create complex compliance requirements that affect global news distribution and revenue models.
Media concentration regulations, foreign ownership restrictions, and editorial independence requirements vary significantly across markets, affecting how news organisations can be structured, funded, and operated whilst potentially influencing editorial decision-making and business strategy development.
Economic Models and Revenue Challenges: The Sustainability Crisis
The news media industry faces a fundamental economic crisis where traditional revenue streams have been systematically undermined by digital disruption, whilst new monetisation models remain inadequate for supporting the scale of journalism that democratic societies require.
Subscription models have shown promise for premium publications like The New York Times, The Financial Times, and The Wall Street Journal, but subscription fatigue limits how many publications most readers will pay for, whilst price sensitivity constrains revenue potential. Freemium models with limited free access attempt to balance audience growth with subscription conversion, but determining optimal paywall strategies remains challenging and varies significantly across publications and audiences.
Advertising-supported models face continued pressure from programmatic advertising that commoditises publisher inventory, ad-blocking software that reduces revenue from existing audiences, and privacy regulations that limit targeting effectiveness. Native advertising and sponsored content create new revenue opportunities but require careful editorial balance to maintain reader trust and regulatory compliance.
Diversified revenue strategies including events, courses, consulting, e-commerce, and membership programmes provide additional income streams but typically require capabilities and resources outside traditional journalism, whilst potentially distracting from core editorial mission and quality.
Conclusion: An Industry in Comprehensive Transformation
The news media industry encompasses an extraordinarily complex ecosystem where traditional and digital platforms compete, collaborate, and depend upon each other in constantly shifting relationships influenced by technological innovation, changing consumer behaviour, regulatory developments, and economic pressures. Success increasingly requires understanding not just individual platforms but their interconnections and the broader technological, economic, social, and political forces shaping information consumption patterns.
Publishers must simultaneously navigate platform dependencies whilst building direct audience relationships, balance free content strategies with sustainable monetisation models, adapt to constantly evolving technological capabilities whilst maintaining editorial standards and public trust, and compete globally whilst serving local community information needs. The industry’s future will likely depend on innovations that can resolve these fundamental tensions whilst creating sustainable economic models for quality journalism in an increasingly complex, competitive, and fragmented information environment.
The challenges facing news media are unprecedented in their scope and complexity, encompassing economic disruption, technological transformation, changing social norms around information consumption, and evolving regulatory frameworks. However, these challenges also create opportunities for fundamental innovation in how news organisations create, distribute, and monetise journalism whilst serving the democratic information needs that remain as crucial today as they were when the printing press first democratised information access centuries ago.
3
News and Me
As far as I can remember, I have been a devoted news consumer. I grew up listening to BBC World Service on shortwave radio, finding comfort in the measured tones and global perspective that connected me to the wider world. Even now, I begin each day with their crisp five-minute bulletin at 4:30 am India time shortly after I wake up. We always had multiple daily newspapers delivered to our door, creating a morning breakfast routine of page turning.
Television in India was dominated by Doordarshan and All India Radio until India’s economic liberalisation opened new channels and perspectives. During my stay in the United States in the late 1980s, I religiously watched the evening network broadcasts on ABC, NBC, and CBS, with ABC’s Peter Jennings becoming my preferred anchor for his authoritative yet approachable delivery style.
For a period, television news in India maintained reasonable balance and journalistic standards before its unfortunate degeneration. As The Economist recently observed with characteristic directness: “Indian TV news long ago relinquished membership of the reality-based community. Night after night presenters praise the government and the prime minister, heap scorn upon the opposition, disparage minorities and foreigners, and insult on-air guests who dare to utter an errant word. The nationalist types who make up the audience treat it as amusement: a kind of World Wrestling Entertainment substitute.” This transformation prompted me to abandon television news consumption entirely several years ago.
My current news diet focuses heavily on technology and business coverage. Techmeme serves as my primary aggregator, supplemented by paid digital subscriptions to The Wall Street Journal, Financial Times, New York Times, Economist, and Bloomberg. Among Indian publications, I particularly value Business Standard and Mint for their analytical depth and editorial independence. Reading now has a secondary purpose: curating interesting snippets for my blog’s Thinks section.
During the IndiaWorld era, news aggregation was central to our mission. I created Samachar.com as India’s first major news aggregator, which became the homepage for millions of Indians globally. This was accomplished through headline scraping—a primitive but effective method in the pre-RSS, pre-Google News era that demonstrated the appetite for curated, comprehensive news consumption.
Despite industry enthusiasm, I haven’t embraced podcasts as extensively as perhaps I should. Reading remains my preferred information consumption method, particularly for the research that informs my blog’s analytical sections. Similarly, I spend minimal time on X (formerly Twitter), preferring to encounter relevant content through my curated reading sources and WhatsApp forwards on a few trusted groups.
Lighter content has always provided welcome relief from serious news consumption. The Sunday comics supplement during my US years was a cherished weekly ritual. During my IIT days, solving The Times of India’s cryptic crossword became a daily intellectual challenge. Today, The New York Times Games—Connections, Wordle, The Mini—provide similar daily mental stimulation.
I subscribe to numerous newsletters, yet they’ve remained frustratingly unchanged through the decades. Their singular focus remains driving clicks to websites or apps where traditional display advertising can be monetised—a model that feels increasingly antiquated and inefficient.
This represents precisely where I see the transformative opportunity: reimagining newsletters as complete experiences within the email inbox itself, powered by ActionAds that eliminate the click-through penalty whilst creating superior user experiences and sustainable monetisation. The future of news consumption lies not in forcing readers away from their inboxes, but in making the inbox itself the destination—rich, interactive, and profitable. This is where NeoMails and NeoN come in.
4
Inbox App…
Imagine receiving a “live” newsletter that fundamentally transforms your morning news routine. Unlike the static, click-hungry newsletters that currently clutter inboxes worldwide, this revolutionary format delivers a complete news experience that never requires leaving your email client. Welcome to the world of NeoMails—where the inbox becomes the destination rather than merely the starting point.
This isn’t your grandfather’s newsletter. Each morning, your personalised news digest arrives with sophisticated gamification elements that make opening genuinely rewarding rather than obligatory. Atomic Rewards (Mu) accumulate with each open, creating habit-forming engagement loops that transform news consumption from a chore into an anticipated daily ritual. These micro-incentives—perhaps points towards prizes, exclusive content unlocks, or community recognition—tap into the same psychological mechanisms that make mobile games irresistibly engaging.
The magic happens when you open the newsletter. Unlike traditional emails frozen in time when sent, NeoMails update dynamically with breaking news, market movements, and developing stories. The content refreshes in real-time, ensuring you’re always receiving the latest information rather than stale headlines that may have been superseded by events. This live updating capability transforms each newsletter into a personalised news portal that rivals dedicated news applications.
Story consumption becomes frictionless through intelligent in-place expansion. Rather than clicking through to external websites—where 80-90% of readers typically abandon their journey—full articles appear as elegant pop-ups within the email itself. This eliminates the “click-through penalty” that has plagued digital publishing for decades whilst providing seamless, uninterrupted reading experiences that maintain reader engagement and attention.
Personalisation extends beyond content curation to encompass advertising integration. AI-powered systems analyse your reading patterns, interests, and engagement history to deliver contextually relevant advertisements that feel like valuable recommendations rather than intrusive interruptions. These aren’t generic banner ads competing for attention, but thoughtfully integrated sponsorships and product recommendations that align with your demonstrated interests and reading behaviour.
Revolutionary ActionAds take this concept further by enabling complete transactions within the email environment. Product demonstrations, service trials, appointment bookings, and purchases can be completed without ever leaving the inbox. Interactive elements like product galleries, booking calendars, and checkout processes appear seamlessly within the newsletter, transforming advertising from awareness-driving interruption to conversion-optimised experience.
Entertainment elements add stickiness and engagement depth. Magnets like daily crossword puzzles, news-related trivia questions, prediction games, and brain teasers can be solved directly within the email, creating additional touchpoints that extend engagement time whilst collecting valuable zero-party data about reader preferences and behaviours.
The underlying technology combines AMP for interactive elements, sophisticated content management systems for real-time updates, and advanced personalisation engines that learn from every interaction. This creates newsletters that function more like applications than traditional communications—dynamic, responsive, and infinitely more engaging than static alternatives.
This represents the logical evolution of news consumption: comprehensive, personalised, interactive experiences delivered directly to the platform where billions already spend significant daily time. NeoMails don’t compete with other news sources for attention—they transform the inbox itself into the ultimate news destination, eliminating friction whilst maximising engagement and monetisation opportunities for publishers brave enough to embrace this paradigm shift.
5
…and In-place Ads
The key to monetising NeoMails lies with NeoN—the revolutionary advertising network that transforms news media newsletters into premium advertising inventory through authenticated identity targeting and frictionless ActionAds integration, enabling any advertiser to reach engaged news readers without disrupting the editorial experience.
NeoN operates on a fundamentally different principle than traditional media advertising. Instead of relying on programmatic advertising that commoditises publisher inventory and drives down rates, NeoN leverages authenticated identity through PII (Personally Identifiable Information) matching to deliver premium, contextually relevant advertising directly within news newsletters from any advertiser category. This creates precision targeting that reaches exactly the right readers whilst generating superior revenue for news publishers.
Reactivation Through News Newsletter Inventory
Consider a premium automotive brand seeking to reconnect with affluent customers who previously test-drove luxury vehicles but didn’t purchase. Traditional approaches require expensive retargeting through Google or Meta, often reaching these prospects across random websites with generic automotive advertising that lacks sophistication and context.
NeoN offers a superior alternative: precision targeting through high-quality news newsletter audiences. The automotive brand’s prospect list is securely matched against engaged readers of business news briefings, financial newsletters, or economic analysis updates. When these affluent prospects open their trusted morning news digest, they encounter a sophisticated ActionAd featuring personalised vehicle recommendations based on their previous showroom interactions.
The entire engagement experience—vehicle configurators, dealership appointment booking, brochure requests, financing calculations—happens within the news newsletter itself through interactive AMP elements. Readers can explore luxury vehicle features, schedule test drives, and access exclusive offers without leaving their trusted news source, whilst the news publisher captures premium advertising revenue from high-value automotive advertising.
New Acquisition Through News Media Audiences
NeoN’s sophisticated Data Management Platform (DMP) capabilities enable advertisers from any category to identify and acquire new customers through authenticated news readership intelligence. News publishers provide valuable audience insights—professional roles, income levels, interests, engagement patterns—derived from voluntary newsletter subscriptions and content interaction patterns.
A premium financial services firm seeking affluent professionals can leverage business newsletter audience intelligence. NeoN’s DMP identifies engaged readers who consume financial news, investment analysis, and economic commentary, indicating strong potential for wealth management services. ActionAds for investment advisory services appear contextually within business briefings, enabling complete consultation booking, portfolio assessment, and service enrollment within the trusted editorial environment.
ActionAds: Premium Integration Within Editorial Context
The true innovation lies in ActionAds’ ability to integrate premium advertising seamlessly within news content whilst maintaining editorial integrity and reader trust. Traditional display advertising in news newsletters often feels intrusive and redirects readers away from valued editorial content. ActionAds enhance the news consumption experience by providing relevant, actionable opportunities within the newsletter format.
Technology newsletters can feature ActionAds from software companies, enabling readers to access product demonstrations, trial sign-ups, and purchase processes directly within their trusted news source. A cybersecurity firm’s ActionAd doesn’t disrupt the editorial flow—it provides relevant security solutions that complement the newsletter’s technology coverage, with complete onboarding possible within the email itself.
Similarly, lifestyle-focused news newsletters can carry ActionAds from luxury hospitality brands, enabling readers to explore exclusive travel packages, restaurant reservations, and experience bookings directly within their morning news digest, creating seamless integration between editorial content and premium advertising opportunities.
The Revenue Revolution for News Media
NeoN creates transformative monetisation opportunities for news publishers: established media brands can generate substantial revenue from their engaged, high-quality readerships whilst maintaining editorial independence and reader trust. ActionAds command premium rates due to their authenticated targeting precision and superior conversion performance, often generating 3-5X higher revenue than traditional display advertising.
The authenticated identity foundation ensures advertising relevance whilst respecting reader privacy, creating sustainable media economics that support quality journalism rather than depending on surveillance-based advertising models that have systematically undermined news media revenue streams.
This represents the future of news media monetisation: premium, permission-based advertising inventory that enhances reader experiences whilst creating substantial, sustainable revenue streams that can fund quality journalism and editorial independence.
6
ZeroCPM as Enabler
The revolutionary unlock for this new world of NeoMails and NeoN lies in the ZeroCPM model—a paradigm shift that eliminates email sending costs for news media companies through revenue sharing with the NeoN platform provider, who absorbs all email delivery expenses whilst monetising the advertising inventory created within newsletters.
This model fundamentally transforms the economics of news publishing by converting email newsletters from cost centres into profit generators. Traditional Email Service Providers (ESPs) charge publishers based on sending volume—typically costing thousands of dollars monthly for major publications reaching hundreds of thousands of subscribers. These costs create perverse incentives where publishers must limit their communication frequency to manage expenses, often resulting in reduced reader engagement and missed monetisation opportunities.
ZeroCPM eliminates this constraint entirely. News publishers can send unlimited newsletters without any delivery costs, enabling them to optimise for reader engagement rather than budget limitations. Daily briefings, breaking news alerts, weekend roundups, and special edition newsletters become economically feasible regardless of subscriber count or sending frequency. This liberation from volume-based pricing enables publishers to rebuild the consistent reader touchpoints that digital disruption has systematically eroded.
Creating Supply: The Inventory Revolution
For news media companies, ZeroCPM creates unprecedented opportunities to expand their email programmes without financial constraints. Publishers who previously limited newsletters to weekly digests can now implement sophisticated email strategies including daily morning briefings, afternoon updates, evening analysis, and weekend features—all without incremental costs.
This expansion creates substantial advertising inventory within engaged, high-quality audiences that advertisers struggle to reach through traditional channels. Financial news newsletters attract affluent professionals, technology publications reach decision-makers and early adopters, whilst lifestyle publications connect with consumer spending influencers. Each newsletter represents premium advertising real estate with authenticated, opted-in audiences that provide superior targeting precision compared to cookie-based alternatives.
The supply creation extends beyond frequency to content sophistication. Publishers can experiment with interactive newsletters, multimedia experiences, and personalised content variations that would be cost-prohibitive under traditional ESP pricing models. This experimentation drives higher engagement rates, stronger reader loyalty, and more valuable advertising inventory that commands premium rates.
Generating Demand: The Advertiser Magnet
NeoN platform providers benefit enormously from this supply expansion, creating advertising inventory that attracts diverse advertisers seeking authenticated, engaged audiences. Unlike programmatic advertising where publishers compete in race-to-the-bottom auctions, NeoN’s authenticated identity model enables premium pricing justified by superior targeting accuracy and conversion performance.
Advertisers gain access to newsletter audiences they cannot reach through social media or search advertising—readers who have explicitly opted into regular communication from trusted news sources. These audiences demonstrate higher engagement levels, longer attention spans, and stronger purchase intent than typical digital advertising targets, justifying premium advertising rates that benefit both publishers and platform providers.
Eliminating Historical Friction
Over recent years, news media companies have systematically reduced their email communication frequency due to inability to monetise website and app traffic effectively. When newsletter clicks generate minimal advertising revenue due to ad-blocking, low engagement, or poor monetisation, publishers naturally limit their email sending to preserve subscriber relationships without overwhelming readers for minimal return.
ZeroCPM NeoMails eliminate this fundamental friction by monetising attention directly within the newsletter itself, transforming every email from a cost-generating communication into a revenue-generating touchpoint that strengthens rather than strains publisher economics whilst providing superior reader experiences.
7
A New Future
The ideas discussed in this essay are not merely for survival, but genuine renaissance for an industry that has spent two decades in managed decline. News media’s path to revival lies not in nostalgic returns to past models, but in embracing revolutionary technologies that restore economic viability whilst enhancing editorial excellence and reader engagement.
The crisis facing trusted journalism runs deeper than simple revenue challenges. In an era of rampant disinformation, conspiracy theories, and algorithmic echo chambers, quality news sources have paradoxically lost ground to less credible alternatives—not because readers don’t value accurate reporting, but because sustainable business models have proven elusive. The economic foundation supporting serious journalism has systematically eroded, creating a vicious cycle where underinvestment in newsrooms reduces content quality, which drives away readers, which further undermines revenue, accelerating the downward spiral.
Most news organisations face stark mathematics: paying subscribers represent typically less than 5% of their readership, whilst traditional advertising revenue has been captured by technology platforms that contribute nothing to content creation costs. Publishers find themselves trapped between subscription models that limit reach and advertising models that generate insufficient revenue, all whilst competing against free, algorithmically-amplified content that prioritises engagement over accuracy.
NeoMails and NeoN offer a genuine alternative that breaks this destructive cycle. Through ZeroCPM economics, publishers can eliminate the financial constraints that have forced them to reduce reader communication frequency, enabling the consistent engagement touchpoints that build reader loyalty and habit formation. When newsletters transform from cost centres into profit generators, publishers can invest in editorial quality rather than cutting newsroom budgets to maintain financial viability.
The win-win-win dynamics create sustainable long-term growth rather than zero-sum competition. Readers benefit from enhanced news experiences that deliver complete stories, real-time updates, and interactive engagement directly within their trusted communication channel, eliminating the friction and distraction of website visits that often fail to convert into meaningful engagement or publisher revenue.
Publishers gain multiple advantages: freed from email delivery costs, they can rebuild direct reader relationships through daily communication; ActionAds generate superior revenue compared to traditional display advertising; authenticated identity targeting commands premium rates that justify editorial investment; and the closed-loop inbox experience protects readers from competing distractions that typically derail attention and engagement.
Advertisers access precisely the audiences they most value—engaged, affluent, educated readers who trust their chosen news sources and demonstrate sustained attention spans. Unlike programmatic advertising that reaches anonymous users across random websites, NeoN enables contextual advertising within editorial environments that enhance rather than degrade user experiences.
This represents journalism’s most promising opportunity in decades: technology that aligns reader preferences, editorial quality, and sustainable economics into a virtuous cycle supporting democratic discourse. Quality journalism thrives when it can be properly funded, and NeoMails with NeoN provide the economic foundation for news media’s renaissance—transforming the inbox into the epicentre of informed civic engagement and financially sustainable journalism.
The future of news isn’t about competing with entertainment for attention—it’s about creating such valuable, engaging experiences that readers actively seek out quality journalism daily, creating the economic foundation for democracy’s essential information infrastructure.
8
A Day in Arun’s Life
Arun’s phone buzzes gently at 6:15 AM with his morning news digest notification. Unlike the intrusive alerts that once plagued his mornings, this comes from his trusted financial newsletter—a publication that has transformed his daily routine since adopting NeoMails six months ago.
Opening his email app, Arun finds his personalised morning briefing has updated itself with overnight market movements from Asian exchanges. The newsletter’s Magnet—today, a quick prediction game about Bitcoin’s daily direction—awards him 15 Mu points for his streak of correct guesses. These micro-rewards have made checking the news feel less like obligation and more like entertainment.
As he scrolls through the digest, Arun notices an ActionAd for premium noise-cancelling headphones perfectly timed for his upcoming business travel. Instead of bookmarking it for later (and inevitably forgetting), he explores product specifications, reads reviews, and completes his purchase directly within the newsletter. The entire transaction takes ninety seconds without leaving his email app, and the headphones will arrive before his departure.
During his morning commute, Arun reads about a developing AI story in his technology newsletter—initially just a brief announcement about a breakthrough at a major tech company. When he reopens the same newsletter during his evening journey home, the story has transformed dramatically. The morning’s single paragraph has expanded into comprehensive coverage featuring expert interviews, market reaction analysis, competitor responses, and regulatory implications that emerged throughout the day. The newsletter’s live updating capability means Arun receives a complete, evolving story rather than fragmented updates across multiple sources. He shares the fully developed analysis with his colleagues, appreciating how his trusted publication has curated the day’s developments into coherent, comprehensive coverage rather than leaving him to piece together information from social media fragments and breaking news alerts.
At lunch, Arun opens his lifestyle newsletter whilst eating. An ActionAd for a new restaurant near his office includes an interactive menu, availability checker, and reservation system. He books a table for Friday evening without downloading another app or visiting another website, appreciating how the advertisement feels more like a useful service than an interruption.
His evening political newsletter includes today’s crossword puzzle, which he completes during his return commute. The puzzle cleverly incorporates current events, making him more engaged with the day’s political developments whilst earning additional Mu points toward monthly prize draws.
Throughout the day, Arun has consumed comprehensive news coverage, engaged with relevant advertising, made purchases, booked reservations, and participated in interactive content—all without leaving his email application once. He’s stayed informed through trusted sources whilst these publishers have generated substantial revenue from his attention and engagement.
Most remarkably, Arun isn’t overwhelmed by information or advertisements despite consuming more news content than ever before. The personalisation algorithms have learned his preferences, the ActionAds feel relevant rather than intrusive, and the interactive elements maintain his engagement without feeling manipulative.
His news consumption has become a seamless blend of information, utility, and light entertainment that enhances rather than disrupts his daily workflow. The publishers he trusts are financially thriving, producing higher-quality journalism funded by innovative advertising models that respect his time and preferences.
This represents the news renaissance in action: engaged readers consuming quality journalism through sustainable economic models that benefit everyone involved. The inbox has become the command centre for informed civic participation, commercial discovery, and meaningful engagement with the world—precisely the revival that seemed impossible just a year earlier.
Arun closes his final newsletter of the day, knowing tomorrow will bring another perfectly curated, interactive, and valuable news experience that makes staying informed a genuine pleasure rather than an overwhelming obligation.